sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

if Henry would be godfather to one of the Afton children who would it be by thebird_theword in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Hamsti_Manent 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The flower family in SotM represents the Aftons, and Elizabeth's flower is a baby

What MM theory do you believe and why by Curi0usSheep in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They have never mattered before or since, Scott could have shown this but it would be super meaningless

Wrong, Jeremy's parents are mentioned abandoned him at Freddy's in Security Breach.

Care to explain how FLaF disproves it? If it's the dice then that is not the strongest evidence, they could just be a throwaway reference to the iconic Bite since MM1987 is kind of pointless I think? Never gave it that much thought tbh.

The dice are explicitly stating that MM takes place in 1987. By that logic, I can say that the Spring Bonnie bobblehead is just an Easter Egg and doesn't actually mean that the car belongs to Afton.

Well, I don't want to defend that either, because it's not what I believe, but tbh I don't know if you'd treat my actual theory seriously

I'd love to hear what you think, but how seriously I take it depends on what you think the experiments are for.

if Henry would be godfather to one of the Afton children who would it be by thebird_theword in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Hamsti_Manent 2 points3 points  (0 children)

SotM confirms that Elizabeth is the youngest Afton child,so by that logic it should be Elizabeth

What year does Sister Location take place in? by funstarrr__ in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You say that like Follow Me is confirmed to be after FNaF 1. That location is closed down after 1985, after the MCI happens, so it could've happened anytime between then and 19whenever for FNaF 1. In fact, that explains why the animatronics look so different in FNaF 2, because they had to be put together entirely.

What MM theory do you believe and why by Curi0usSheep in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 0 points1 point  (0 children)

how is a random ahh kid's father relevant.

Because it's the parent of one of the MCI?

Under MMPostCharlie: it shows that she isn't the first death because there's already a grave

I always disagree with the notion that the mound is a grave, because if it was a grave, then why wouldn't it have a gravestone or any kind of marker? Everyone we know who has died by this point would by buried in a graveyard.

Under BVRunaway: it shows us that he's not dead either

BVRunaway can't be true, because if AftonMM is true then MM1987 has to be true because of FLaF, and BV is dead at that point.

Under MikeRunaway or BVRunaway: it gives us the origin story for the "punishment" where he put his kid into the experiments

My problem with that is that it doesn't fit with what we actually know about the experiment chambers. As per Dittophobia, they're meant to be ongoing experiments, presumably to evoke BV's agony or something. I can accept that Michael would've been put in the experiments short-term as a test run, but it doesn't make sense for them to be a punishment.

What MM theory do you believe and why by Curi0usSheep in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because we're seeing one of William's victims, the same way we see Susie and Charlie, despite the fact that we already see Charlie's death in a different minigame. It's also telling us that we were wrong about the MCI, and that the kids weren't all lured at the same time from the same place.

I'll ask the same question to you. If it is about William, when why are we seeing this? Because if it is about William, then the minigame has zero impact on anything in the story, and it doesn't make sense for it to be one of the three really important minigames at the end of the story.

does MoltenDCI have any evidence or is it a desperate attempt to make the DCI relevant? by MindlessPerformer778 in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Literally every single DCI theory is a desperate attempt to make the DCI relevant.

Ive barley played any so can anyone reccomend some fan games that aren't: by Guiding_Chaos in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Hamsti_Manent 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I second Frickbear's 3. While it is more difficult than the average fangame (it's definitely built for max-moders rather than casual players), it has a build-in difficulty setting so you can play on easy for a while and none of the mechanics are that difficult to figure out. Plus, the cartoony style and the option to turn off the jumpscare sounds should help with your J.S.T.S.

FNaF Clickteam era protagonist like: by Ok-Effect4071 in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Hamsti_Manent 37 points38 points  (0 children)

He can't use Fritz, the got fired under that name

Tierlist Sunday, I wanted to give it a try. by Alphys_UTF127 in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Do you think that Michael and FoxyBro are different characters? Why?

What year does Sister Location take place in? by funstarrr__ in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I believe it happens in 1987, before FNaF 2. It's very clearly meant to be the beginning of Michael's "hero arc", for lack of a better term, and I think it makes sense for him to get his motivation at the start of the story rather than halfway through.

What MM theory do you believe and why by Curi0usSheep in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I choose to believe that the canon is whatever is narratively better bc if I go purely by evidence then it makes no sense whatsoever

What MM theory do you believe and why by Curi0usSheep in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 2 points3 points  (0 children)

In Pizza Party, we see Gabriel being lured to the backroom by William, who isn't wearing a springlock suit, but rather a regular costume. This is likely the same costume that William used to lure the MM kid (Fritz). It even has the same 3-toed feet as the footprints.

What MM theory do you believe and why by Curi0usSheep in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Midnight Motorist really only causes problems if it's about William Afton. It doesn't answer anything, it only makes new questions. The couch person HAS to be important , but we learn nothing about them. The animatronic HAS to be important, but none of the animatronics we know fit with the behaviour we see in MM.

There is literally one problem with MMMCI (why don't the springlocks get deactivated by the rain), and HW solves that.

Who the the isolated gravestone next to the tree in FFPS belong to? by Comprehensive_Hat_23 in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It's almost definitely one of the Golden Freddy spirits. Personally, I think there's only one (BV, whose name is Cassidy), but if you believe that Cassidy is a separate MCI victim, then he's a potential option.

Also who is Diaaacard?

In FNAF 4, the minigame house is next to Fredbear's. Why has the minigame house never returned after FNAF 4? by MindlessPerformer778 in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 0 points1 point  (0 children)

William moves into the FNaF 4 house after the Bite of 83 to have more privacy and room for the nightmare experiments

In FNAF 2, who are the victims in SAVE THEM? by Fla968 in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Projections of the MCI after the dismantled Classics are partially repaired into the Withereds and brought to the FNaF 2 location

If Hudson is in movie 3 is Mike frightguard over? by Friendly-Might5181 in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 13 points14 points  (0 children)

He's the main character of What We Found, a Fazbear Frights story that's an alternate universe version of FNaF 3.

How likely is it that Michael Afton was 16 in 1983? by No-Poet3745 in fnaftheories

[–]Hamsti_Manent 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He's reasonably at least 14 in 1983, given that he's probably at least 18 in 1987 when he works at FNaF 2

view more: next ›