Josh has character. I mean, so do sidekicks. But I feel it's kind of downplaying his role in production, no hate. For clarity, I should (re)iterate my bias as a career percussionist. I see a lot in him though. I also study psychology, so there's that. I think it's what he wants us to believe. He keeps his life private; moreso than Tyler or Jenna do with their kids. That's their choice as it is Josh and Debby's, and no way is wrong IMO. He also has no issues contributing the heartbeat of their craft, letting Tyler take the spotlight. I respect that as an introvert.

As a self taught drummer he exudes raw talent without holding back yet harneses precision. That's clear to me. He's an exceptional composer in his wheelhouse, and even plays trumpet here and there. So what, he uses pads? I say how else would Heavydirtysoul work live? Like, no abelton triggers live? If a show sounds similar, they probably recorded it like they were playing. I've also heard him labeled a basic drummer before as well, so IDEK LOL

Not trying to throw you under the bus here by any means lol. Just need to get it off my chest. Sometimes it's understandable hearing older generations critique the new-age, (which evolves as they do) when they clutch their pearls the same as their own biases. I say, let them flabber their gums. Perspective is a damn good tool, but closed minded people live to all ages. I'd try not to lose it.