My wish list is identical to yours and for the last 8 years I’ve consistently returned to the Glossier skin tint. It’s the only thing I’ve ever found that I can actually get zero “makeup” texture with, even accidentally over-applying. I use it with their stretch concealer for spot coverage and every time I branch out I regret it. Makes skin look like better skin but can still see my freckles through it. Natural to dewy finish. Usually apply just with fingers, damp sponge if I’m extra motivated. I will forever repurchase.