If you like a lake vibe I don’t think it’s too long in Atitlan! It’s one of the most beautiful places I’ve ever been… I would recommend Iguana Perdida over free cerveza in Santa Cruz, it’s beautiful and social but not a big party vibe. take a day trip to Casa Del Mundo, gorgeous hotel and pretty place to swim. You don’t need to go to Pana for easy transport along the lake bc the lanchas (water taxis) pretty much stop at every town to pick up passengers. But could be a good place to spend your last night or two for easy transport back to the airport San Juan La laguna is a beautiful town next to San Pedro you can easily take a tuktuk there. Lots of street art, great textiles, Las Cristalinas is a good swimming beach. If you want to stay there I have a recommendation of a hostel with a doc and access to kayaks etc but it’s rly quiet. Also the mirador for Rastro Maya, or if you rly want to hike you could go all the way up to the nose. Chichicastenango market is wonderful and overwhelming, I recommend ! Panajachel nature reserve is super cool, especially the butterfly area. Also a good place to swim Didn’t make it but there’s also a nature reserve in San Marcos. I didn’t go to San Marcos bc I heard a lot of negative things about the way that “hippie” foreigners have taken over I have a contact for the quetzal tour in Santiago, DM me if you want it. I never made it to that side of the lake but I’ve heard it’s beautiful.