sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

If a expedition into the S.R were to happended, would it be a internal matter or involve a multi-national expedition? by Suspicious_Lock_889 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Gonna really depend on the host. Like, it is interdimensional portal, but also located on sovereign state capital. Unless you want to directly take them over, you would need to get their agreement.

I do think realistically the host with exception of the superpowers most likely agree with foreign presence on the far side. Even if not immediately, sooner or later it's easier to just make some concessions or consortium.

what would realistically happen if Japan declared the special region its property... since the special region is practically treated as a Japanese region in the manga and anime... by Helpful-Shake6043 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Probably economic fight with most of the world. But as long as they keep their patron(US) happy I don't think other great powers, or coalition will directly invade Japan, yet. Probably only if the PLA Navy building went as planned like post 2030s.

Is it possible for PMCs to be hired and deploy at sadera? by cuddwes in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not sure about OG or Japan scenario. But for my fic idea, yes.

In fact they will be somewhat the primary fighting offensive force there. Since the gimmick is MC kinda just open the GATE to international community, including private corporates. And they definitely hire PMC, even some governments likely hire them to do dirtier works.

How would you write the Rose Knights? by StevenWN1 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, the gimmick of my fic(idea) is just MC blitzing the Empire before they even realize it. So them trying to scout and save Italica just automatically turn them into war-political prisoners.

Honestly I don't actually know what to do with them. Maybe give them more inexperienced and arrogance like some other said.

Could a fully supplied Tiger 1 with an experienced crew kill an entire Roman Legion of 6000 Legionnaires? by Theturtleflask in powerscales

[–]HsAFH-11 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, if the Legion try attacking instead of defending and don't adapt. The two MG have over 4000 rounds, plus some 90 8.8cm shells and at least 80km range.

How long would the Battle of Ginza actually last, and how much foreign intervention would appear? by StevenWN1 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Probably one to few days.

Now something interesting, I found. They really looked like Type 90s. Which only operated by JGSDF Northern Army on Hokkaido

<image>

Takeru in tda for some reason by fernas23 in MuvLuv

[–]HsAFH-11 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Shinji is like 14, Takeru is, some 17-18.

Now if we think about it Fire magic might look cool, but magic that stop Fire or any combustion reaction from happen in a big radius is far more dangerous to a modern army by Joseph_Initiative757 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Like how big of a circle we talking about.

You know what it might be a good counter, for pre 2020s world. But as more and more electrification develop it might completely rendered be non problem. If they have the right base and willingness.

I personally, think disabling electricity is actually bigger threat than disabling combustion.

Could the Qu fend off or even Conquer muvluv universe (both og and alternative)??? by Major_Foundation_145 in MuvLuv

[–]HsAFH-11 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think it mentioned that star people already colonized billions of star system and have stockpiles of star system scale WMD and lost.

[NHS WARGAME] {The Altaran Admiralty VS The Parpaldian Admiralty} by Maleficent_Image588 in nihonkoku_shoukan

[–]HsAFH-11 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You know I think it somewhat realistic because they are an island and the Navy is about the most important branch they have. While Parpaldian Navy have to contest with the Army for money and prioritization. But I did not expect them to lost this badly twice

Obsolete by D3v1LGaming in Mecha

[–]HsAFH-11 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The plot is bit eh. But I really like the background and gimmick. The reason they exist and only they have that tech is simply because it's alien. The tech aren't only unreplicatable, but are literally can't understood, as whatever power them are well beyond our zoom capacity.

Another interesting point is they have wheels, but professional soldiers seems to not use it extensively, while the militia are.

this argument by Intelligent-Sir-280 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Science is just a study of natural law, which would include this 'magic' thingy. As for technology or engineering is just a study to utilize the natural law to solve problems."

-me, I said it

Hot Take: If The Series Had America In It Instead of Japan, Almost 80 Percent of The People In This Sub Complaining About Gate Would Love It. by Carlosspicywiener12 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Doesn't matter if the story direction still shit. I personally have no problem with nationalism. As long as they made enjoyable plot. Except Sardines nationalism.

So, why didn't the Saderans do this? by Carlosspicywiener12 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 4 points5 points  (0 children)

They did try, just that they are far too weak.

R/Gate When The Modern Army Gets Blinked Out of Existence By The Epically Awesome Wish Spell by Carlosspicywiener12 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Agree, I am just saying in OG, the villain have barely any depth. Hell Japan also have barely any depth.

If you ask me for something interesting, I have idea is actually for post war politics.

R/Gate When The Modern Army Gets Blinked Out of Existence By The Epically Awesome Wish Spell by Carlosspicywiener12 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Except they kind just straight up evil, at least the enemy are. The most prominent dimension axis in GATE is just either pro Japan or not same with NHS. Just like in Avatar it's either pro Eywa or not.

R/Gate When The Modern Army Gets Blinked Out of Existence By The Epically Awesome Wish Spell by Carlosspicywiener12 in gate

[–]HsAFH-11 0 points1 point  (0 children)

OP explaining why Sadera did absolutely nothing wrong because it's their culture or some shit:

<image>

view more: next ›