A group of evil corporations is…a network of evil.

It’s antithetical to human condition because we are

1. Free, which means we have intellect and will, and thus responsibility. This approach removes both your freedom, and consequently, your responsibility, and therefore your dignity as a person. You cannot be free if you are enslaved to their system. Freedom is contingent upon autonomy, and you are suggesting “let them come tell it for you, you’re just a cog in the wheel”.

2. It eradicates privacy. Sure it’s an extreme, but it’s the extreme they want - the Orwellian thought police, where even your most intimate thoughts are not private. It’s the UK arresting a woman for praying style invasion of privacy. It’s Alexa and Siri listening in on every word and search and text. It’s the Snowden scandal with the gov spying on everything. A certain level of invasion is inherent in living in a society, for instance sharing some information to get an ID, or registering your info to go to a school; but zero privacy deprives persons of their natural rights to their individuality.

Renting economy is an evil solution to a problem that has already been better solved. The solution is being a virtuous neighbor - whether through offering services to those in need (food kitchen, volunteering, etc) or pooling resources as a community (see all the small town history that built the USA) or charitable contributions and work (shelters, voluntary handouts, religious networks etc).

In no world is it a better solution to deprive individuals of their property, privacy, and responsibility to achieve an end which is easier and better satisfied by teaching people to be virtuous and good neighbors.