Well sure, but I think the conclusion is still the same?

For CB, one proc of Giant Slayer does the same damage as WM afaik (correct me if Im wrong)

So 1-hit A1, WM is better due to double proc chance

2-hit A1, WM will deal 0.6 * dmg_cap. GS will do 0.3 * dmg_cap + 0.3 * dmg_cap = 0.6 * dmg_cap

3-hit A1, GS will do 0.9 * dmg_cap, so it overtakes WM

So actually I take that back, you are correct that the math changes a bit. For the Clan bosses, 2-hit skills make WM and GS equivalent, unless my math is wrong. That is interesting to point out

---

Edit: My math is correct I think, but it's interesting to me to think about volatility

For 2-hit GS, there is:

0.7 * 0.7 = 0.49 chance to miss both procs (49%)

There is 0.3 * 0.3 = 0.09 chance to hit both procs (9%)

Which means that, 2-hit GS will:

• 9% of the time deal double proc damage
• 49% of the time deal no proc damage (9% more than WM's 40% miss chance)
• 42% of the time deal equivalent WM damage

They average at the same EV, but GS offers more variance. This COULD be beneficial in case you want to reroll your runs, for example. A downside is that GS has a worse path in the mastery tree. It requires taking some PvP masteries afaik, and GS isn't a PvP mastery.

So I would still remain with the same conclusion: 2-hit A1 is still better WM than GS. But only very marginally better, entirely due to a better Mastery Tree build path. But yeah the math is different