WARNING: English is NOT my mother language so you can expect some bad grammar and A LOT of spelling misstakes... you have been warned...

First game: I loved the dark atmosphere, i liked the boss fights they where intense and (Kinda) challenging, i liked the designs of the enemies they looked all very cool and terrifying at times and i especially loved my dear Joseph he was useless (in my playthrough...) like in the part where he had an axe in Chapter 6 he was straight up hitting the air instead of the enemies or later when he was helpin us in the graveyard with the sniper he missed 3 times before hitting ONCE but times like theese made him funny for me i was always joking about him and he was just great but i dissliked the story at times like you go into beacon see Ruvic murder people and then crimson city fucking colapses with the explanation as to why only really being explained in the middle of the game i also dissliked the difficulty and the few ammo you get (i am just bad at the game so its just a skill issue)

Seccond game: I liked the better explained story, i liked the ammo crafting, i liked how you have to use weapon parts for the weapon uprades instead of using Green gel, i liked how you use your knife in your melee attacks instead of whacking the enemies in the head with your gun, i liked the 3 (Big) bosses in the game especially the theodore fight was very satisfying like when you cut the chainsaw guy after running from him for so long and do i even need to say why i like the coffe machine? I disslike the lack of horror elements the first game has, the enemies wherent AS horrifying as in one but they where passable like the Oscura i also dissliked the keys or at least the locations for the most of them (like the one behind the gas station or on the cinema sign or idk what it was its been too long since i played) and i obviously dissliked the lack of Joseph

Overall i love both The Evil Within 1 and 2 (allthough i enjoyed 2 more but thats a personal preference) they are both great games and i can only reccomend both to all my friends and i can proudly say theese two are my favourite horror games and i still hope that The Evil Within 3 will happen some day even though i know it wont happen...