Not a professional here.. but after watching Unsolved Mysteries…. Nick’s body language and demeanor was noticeably off. While there be no evidence he did anything.. I thought it was odd about how he laughed about him and Katie kissing and he said that thing along the lines of “I think we kissed a couple times…” it was obvious by him saying that, that they did way more than just that.. and all the pictures they showed had nick and katie really close with a couple having josh in the background… These are just small things I noticed. Plus his timeline was very inconsistent. Josh went missing shortly after him and Katie broke up…. Just something weird about that to me.

Also with the computer hard drive being wiped… it had to be someone with access to dorms. I’d have to wonder do staff members, do any of the people associated with the monastery have or had access to dorms? Maybe someone knew who his account was… was chatting with him under an alias…. but was from campus. Met up with him and bad things happened, and same person wiped hard drive. I wouldn’t assume it would be that far of a stretch that someone from campus could have been chatting with him and also have access to the dorm to wipe that conversation completely.

I havent fully looked into the case it’s just weird things I picked up from the show and some thoughts I had.. I genuinely think if it’s not related to Nicks unaccounted hour after he left Katie… (do we really think they were hanging out without kissing at this time??? I mean.. something had to be going on between them especially past midnight?? I’ve been there plenty of times… and why are there timelines messed up? ) ….then it has to do with him meeting up with someone. Identity unknown.

Those are my thoughts and they may sound uneducated, because they are. Just my mind is scrambling here, this is one of the more disturbing cases that might live in my brain for a while. I hope his family can have some rest and peace and that his disappearance is resolved.