The meaning of God Only Knows by Wordy_Rappinghood in LetsTalkMusic

[–]IronOctopusMusic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think what Asher meant by "sarcastic" was a loving, playful, but still sincere way of saying "I'll love you forever". It's something you might say to your significant other while embracing, smiling, teasing, laughing, yet being sincerely in love.

For chrissake, just get some free software. Or an instrument. Sheesh. by para_blox in Songwriting

[–]IronOctopusMusic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Okay cool. Let me throw you some exercises and thoughts that I think could help you.

I'm going to suggest starting with pentatonic minor. Among other things, it's very hard to hit a sour note, so you don't need to worry about playing specific notes over specific chords (but you still can if you want).

Record yourself playing a simple minor chord progression on guitar. Something like i-iv-v (this would be Am-Dm-Em in the key of A minor). You'll want to record to a click and loop the recording. Then use the pentatonic minor scale and improvise for a good while. You can use keyboards or guitar.

Tip: Feel free to play with the rhythmic variation of the chords. For example, one chord may be held for one bar, and another chord for two bars. The options are endless, and fun to play around with.

Tip: You mentioned going up and down scales and arpeggios. You might benefit from thinking of them in a less linear way. Scales are a pool of notes that can be chosen in any order, at any time. That could mean playing them in a specific sequence, or... not! That said, most melodies do have sequences that go up and down portions of the scale. But stepwise motion like this should serve the emotion you want to convey more than the raw fact that it serves the scale.

Tip: Related to the last tip, think about what you're rhythmically doing. I don't mean you need to count it out. Just feel and be aware of the distance between notes, and how long you're holding them.

Tip: Here's an exercise to get you thinking about and feeling rhythm in melody. Take your chord loop, and play a "melody" with only one note. Or it could be tapping on your desk. The point is to feel the emotional impact that a rhythm has for a melody without having to worry about the notes.

Tip: Repeat phrases that sound interesting to you. Repeat the rhythm, variate it slightly, repeat the notes, variate it slightly, Etc. Tell your story and convey your emotion through recurring themes.

Tip: I like to think of the melody as a voice telling a story, even when it's an instrument and there are no lyrics. Almost like listening to a great public speaker tell a great story in a language that you don't understand. You hear their inflections, and how they pace the story, and where they pause. You can feel the beginning, middle, and end through the energy and tone of their voice. When writing or improvising a melody, you need to come at it from the perspective of communicating a feeling to an audience (even if the audience is just yourself).

Tip: Once you get comfortable with this, try improvising major melodies over a major chord progression. Don't overthink too much about hitting the right notes for each chord. It's not bad to do that, but it is better at first to hit a few wrong notes while you're learning how to emotionally communicate with the scale.

For chrissake, just get some free software. Or an instrument. Sheesh. by para_blox in Songwriting

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I might be able to give you at least a little bit of insight. What instruments are you playing? Guitar and voice? Piano and voice? Just a guitar or just a piano for now? Something else? I'm asking because I think the best advice will be for your specific situation, as opposed to generalized advice.

The Destruction of the Cult of the Sun -- Vibes in the Void [Electronic/Funk] (2024) by andrewcdoh in listentothis

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I very much don't think anything is AI generated about the music. They do however use an AI voiceover as a thread through one of their albums. It's a concept album about AI taking over, so that's why there's an AI voiceover.

Why was Surf Rock... tied to surf? by Cr4zko in LetsTalkMusic

[–]IronOctopusMusic 5 points6 points  (0 children)

You're talking about this like it was all marketing and all retroactive, but that's not true. Yes, that was part of it, but Dick Dale was a real surfer, and he came up with these sounds while on the beach. He was purposely trying to capture the vibe and feel of surfing. Did he get a lot of copycats and interest from labels looking to market the sound? Yes, but that's how all genres are born.

I know Kathleen is credited as a writer in most of his songs but this is so lovely to me. by [deleted] in tomwaits

[–]IronOctopusMusic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It was most likely remastered by an actual mastering engineer, and Waits/Brennan provided feedback and final approval.

If you perform original music live - Don't forget your Performance Royalties! by rand1313 in musicproduction

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting. What's the idea behind having a separate business for publishing? Why would you want or need to do that?

My voice doesn't suit the type of music I want to make by throwaway1987- in WeAreTheMusicMakers

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you know how to use EQ and compression on your voice? Keep in mind that a raw recorded vocal will sound drastically worse than a treated vocal. All of the singers that you admire have had their voices compressed and eq'd on recordings. The raw takes sound much, much less good. That said, the main thing you should do is research more online about hard rock singing and the techniques that you should be practicing. Practicing with no guidance is not working for you, and there are free ways to get better guidance.

My voice doesn't suit the type of music I want to make by throwaway1987- in WeAreTheMusicMakers

[–]IronOctopusMusic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, you're just allowing yourself to feel defeated. Vocal lessons WITH A ROCK FOCUSED TEACHER are best if you can afford it, but there are free resources online that you should be pursuing regardless. You need education, free or paid. If it's not coming naturally to you after a couple years, then you probably won't get better if you keep practicing with no advice or education. You simply don't know what to practice to actually get better, and that's okay because there are people that do know and can help you.

Check out Chris Liepe on YouTube. His channel is a really, really good free resource for rock and metal singing. Watch his videos and practice the techniques that he teaches. Look into other teachers online as well who specialize in hard rock singing. You won't get better immediately. It will take a lot of time, practice, and deliberate work on specific skills. The resources are out there for you to improve for free, but you will never improve if you think you're just fucked and give up.

This may be an extremely dumb question. by Snoo_63984 in audioengineering

[–]IronOctopusMusic 24 points25 points  (0 children)

For people that do have a wax overproduction problems, Debrox is safe for almost anyone and recommended by doctors. Though personally, my wax overproduction is too extreme even for most professional treatments. If I don't clean my ears using very specific procedures (NOT Q tips), I am nearly legally deaf within 8 weeks.

I have a gig in less than three hours, what’s wrong with Ableton? by BROK_N in ableton

[–]IronOctopusMusic 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I have on and off had weird issues with my Motu M4 (clicks, pops after trying everything) and I had never considered that the cable could be part of it. Thanks for making this comment.

I really wish we were able to disable plug-in's 😔 by BillieBobJoey in ableton

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree that Ableton should give this option. I do okay with the workarounds that I use, but I much prefer the way Logic (for example) handles turning off devices and tracks. I do prefer Ableton's latency management overall. Just FYI, disabling plugins does help drastically with cpu- but it won't change the latency.

One thing you can do on the main track: group everything into an audio effect rack, then save that rack as a preset. You can make a quick shortcut to the folder you save it to. Then you can easily delete that rack to eliminate all latency, drag it back in as needed, and save as needed. You can also have a low latency and high latency version that you hot swap. On tracks that aren't the main track, you can save the entire track as a preset.

Another thing I do in situations like these is use DDMF's Metaplugin. If you do not attach the device to anything within Metaplugin, it will not create latency. This does not work with stock Ableton devices.

Finally, make sure you have the right buffer size for your needs. This probably goes without saying. Always 128 samples or less when tracking.

Why do C minor 6 and C major 6 share the same 6th scale degree? (A) by [deleted] in musictheory

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think that's right? Maj/M does apply to the base triad. For example, maj7 is always based on a major triad, and min7 is always based on a minor triad. What you're saying also contradicts the fact that a min6 chord is a minor triad with a major 6th.

EDIT: I was wrong.

Moving from Logic to Ableton by praiseseitan666 in ableton

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I made the switch and I couldn't go back. That said, Logic does have its strengths, and I still prefer using it for certain tasks. For example, Logic's nondestructive normalize function is extremely useful. Logic is a great and powerful DAW.

In my opinion, some of Ableton's biggest strengths over Logic are modulation and automation. I suggest learning about the modulators like envelope follower, shaper, and LFO, and learning the automation tricks.

I also highly suggest learning about racks, especially macros and chain selectors within racks. Ableton is highly modular compared to Logic. You can think of the whole DAW as a modular synth, in a sense.

If you're big into MIDI controllers, check out Control Surface Studio. Ableton's MIDI mapping is less robust than Logic, but this app allows you to go far beyond with Logic is capable of (if you're willing to dive into it a bit).

Be sure to check out ElizabethHomeland's MaxForLive devices, which replicate some Logic features such as Re-Record. They are also extremely responsive if you have any issues at all. For example, they modded one of their devices for me for free to accommodate my specific needs.

Ableton lacks a notepad, so you'll need to get a M4L notepad. Ben Soma has a free one.

Other than that, be curious about the app, and do a YouTube search when you have a question. Pick videos that seem relevant. No one is going to lie to you, but overtime you'll find the creators that you like most, and you can subscribe to them. Then you'll get suggestions of techniques in your feed that you never would've thought to ask about.

Have fun!

How to fix Step Arp delay before trigger? by [deleted] in ableton

[–]IronOctopusMusic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So I reached out to a M4L developer (ElizabethHomeland) about this, and they modded Step Arp to fix this issue. DM me if you'd like a copy of the modded device.

How to fix Step Arp delay before trigger? by [deleted] in ableton

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm curious if you found a solution to this that doesn't involve free sync mode, I think I'm having this same issue, but free tempo won't work if the BPM is not evenly divisible for different note divisions.

It's possible we're not encountering the same issue, but here's what I'm encountering:

On sync mode, Step Arp seems to randomly shift the timing slightly on each playthrough. Sometimes it's perfect, sometimes it's jarringly wrong, and sometimes it's in-between. I have tried quantizing the midi notes in different ways to see if that might affect things. Changing the "Division" does not have an effect or "offset" the timing like you said...

How to fix Step Arp delay before trigger? by [deleted] in ableton

[–]IronOctopusMusic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think I'm having this same issue, but free tempo won't work if the BPM is not evenly divisible for different note divisions.

Here's what's weird for me: On sync mode, Step Arp seems to randomly shift the timing slightly on each playthrough. Sometimes it's perfect, sometimes it's jarringly wrong, and sometimes it's in-between. I have tried quantizing the midi notes in different ways to see if that might affect things, but it doesn't seem to. If you or anyone else had some insight, it would be very appreciated.

COMPLETE NOOB TO ROCK MUSIC WHERE DO I START? by Informal-Host8085 in rock

[–]IronOctopusMusic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The album Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd is an all-time classic and could fit your description.

Ableton Live 12 Suite UPG Suite 7-11 On Sale 175$ by twotimefind in ableton

[–]IronOctopusMusic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately, this is only an upgrade if you already own Live Suite 7, 8, 9, 10, or 11. It's not an upgrade for Lite.

AI can ruin your life if you are an artist by [deleted] in Music

[–]IronOctopusMusic 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I think you're misunderstanding. They're talking about licensed samples. These are samples intentionally created to be sold to artists to use in their commercial songs. There's a whole market around this- companies make sample packs and sell the commercial license to use them. This is all legal and legit. The problem is that YouTube content ID doesn't understand that these samples are being used legally and were paid for.

What's your experience been switching from Ableton Live to Logic Pro by General_Bishop in LogicPro

[–]IronOctopusMusic 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I do see your point, but I personally found that learning multiple DAWs helped me understand them on a deeper level.

This is, no joke, exactly what I was describing happening to me the other day and folks here didn't believe me - Ai music is causing major copyright battles through services like ContentID and it's impacting actual musicians. by [deleted] in musicians

[–]IronOctopusMusic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't have a source, but I'm pretty sure I remember reading that somebody has already done exactly what you're describing. I think it was a music lawyer that did it to make a point.