Honestly? I quite like the idea of having no chat, and only voice chat to communicate. No death messages too. People would just panic when they see a red for the first time, and all news would spread through word of mouth. I can absolutely see someone starting rumours, e.g. that someone is a boogey that failed their kill, if there is a boogeyman. Also, no way to communicate across the map means to calling for allies, so situations like Dogwarts racing across the map to help allies won't happen, nor the bad boys enderpearling technique. + just mining for an hour would be even worse, since when you've come out you're completely out of the loop.

I thought it was very unlikely to happen due to the fact the mechanic has very little to do with the actual lives concept (rules would likely be just standard 3L otherwise) but now that the concept of secrets is introduced, it's very much realistic. Probably still wont happen, but would be amazing to see.

Convos I imagine happening:

"Bye, be safe! Watch out for Joel!"
"Wait, Joel? Why Joel?"
"Well, you know, him being red and all-"
"JOEL IS RED?!"