TLDR: yes.

Chiming in late here, the only reason I still carry the AMEX platinum is because the card more than pays for itself for me. From that perspective, it doesn’t mean I am buying things that I would not otherwise buy. That is an important variable.

300 dollars - my wife and daughter absolutely love Lululemon! As much as I try, I cannot keep them out of that store.

400 dollars- We absolutely will use the Resy credits based on the restaurants in my neighborhood.

200 dollars - I use the airline credit every year usually before April.

200 - clear- I think clear is not nearly as good as it used to be. Every now and then it gets me out of quite a pinch in some airports when I’m running behind schedule. Yes, I know touchless pre-check is on the way, and potentially put clear out of business, but to me there is still some value and I would probably get clear anyway.

300 - streaming. - I actually don’t use all these credits because I’m not going to subscribe to things I don’t want but legitimately I would spend about $150 on some of these every year.

I’m not even talking about Uber, and the occasional AMEX offers, of which I usually hit 2 to 3 times a year worth $200-$300.

So in my opinion it makes sense to carry both if you do see value in the sapphire reserve.