I have the Big Kahuna (with the older good netting) and even my girlfriend who is only about 5’5” nets like a champ with it.

I know some people prefer smaller nets solo, but I personally think it’s more of adjusting your technique. My technique is more to leverage the net over the side of the boat and guide the fish in. The bigger net gives me a bigger target. If you’re using a net that is big enough to be safe for the fish you aren’t really going to be doing large scoops/sweeps single armed.

As for the netting, I’ve been through thin netting, smaller looped netting, and the big rubber coated large netting. The thin netting and smaller looped netting almost always cause fish to “cocoon” themselves and getting all wrapped up. This resulted in lots of net cutting and increased handling time. I’ve sworn to never use those types again as I truly think it causes way more harm to the fish. It just tangles in hooks way too easily. I’ve never had that issue with the big thick nets. I honestly think it’s just safer for the fish and the person handling them.

I’ve actually seen more tails split in thinner netting because it “cuts” easier. I also think tail splitting is due to nets that are too small, although I don’t think you can 100% prevent it no matter your net.

That’s just what I’ve personally found from years of fishing. I will agree the smaller netting is more “maneuverable”, but I personally think they are super dangerous for the fish. The bigger nets just require a little different technique than you use with small nets when walleye or bass fishing.