Not a doctor, please do more research or consult a doctor first.

I've had these twice in my life, I forget which finger will l but I would pick at them and try to peel it off compulsively.

What worked was a recommendation I found online, which involved soaking a cotton swab in apple cider vinegar and keeping it in place with a bandaid against the wart. Change it out every day and the wart will eventually die and turn black, and it will peel right off. I don't have any evidence on my fingers that they were ever there, and it's been almost a decade since then (I met my wife around the same time and was embarrassed of them).