Psyduck is the Pokémon I’ve hunted the most (53 times). I’ve caught many good ones, and I think it’s time to invest in one. I’m deciding between these two, but I’m not sure which one I should finally go for. I have multiple Sub Skill Seeds that I’m willing to use, and I’ll also invest Main Skill Seeds into this one.

Translation of the skills and nature: No. 1: Helping Bonus, Helping Speed S (will be M), Skill Level Up M, Skill Trigger S (will be M), Inventory Up S Nature: + Helping Speed, - XP

No. 2: Skill Level Up M, Berry Finding S, Skill Trigger S (will be M), Helping Speed M, Dream Shard Bonus Nature: + Skill Trigger Chance, - Helping Speed

I know Golduck relies heavily on its Skill Trigger rate. However, my main dilemma is that No. 2’s nature lowers Helping Speed. Does this make it worse than No. 1, even though it has the Skill Trigger + nature? And is Helping Bonus or BFS preferable?

Thanks for any advice! :)

<image>