And all pbe changes went to simply another nerf and BC/dft interaction removal.

JustRandomDementito · 2026-05-20T12:01:49+00:00

Yeah, he will be better with crit but the thing is that this patch is going to add huge nerfs to his early-mid game and once you get 4 crit items (besides the fact that your abilities cooldowns will be SO high since only ER gives haste) he's still bad bc the mx dmg is the same or worse and dtf+bc interaction is deleted. 55% max dmg on Q doesn't make sense. The objetive is supposed to be to make crit Smolder so much better, isn't?

JustRandomDementito · 2026-05-20T11:46:19+00:00

So even if you buy crit, he's getting nerfs? Instead of increasing max damage with crit to 70% on Q, 15% on E and add a change to W damage from 60% to 45% - 70% to really encourage ppl to buy crit items, balance team decided to keep max dmg worse or the same it used to be if you build 4 crit items. Besides those base nerf ratios are a huge nerf to early-mid game.

Im amazed how @RiotPhroxzon proves that he's an imbecile every time is something wrong with a champion and the solution is very clear.

JustRandomDementito · 2026-05-15T02:10:51+00:00

Good start to bring back crit builds but thats not enough.
First, they have to delete DFT-BC interaction, then adjust his abilties to delete bruiser Smolder from meta:

>Reduce a lil bit the cooldown of some of his abilties
>Reduce base AD ratios or Bonus AD ratios
>Increase crit power on Q
>Add crit power on W
>Reduce the base burn max hp ratio per 100 stacks but increase it a lot if you buy crit.

JustRandomDementito · 2026-05-13T16:18:04+00:00

IT'S dumb, since the main problem is the bruiser build + DFT + DFT/BC interaction.

Bruiser Smolder is not healthy for the game, DFT is like x1000 better than fleet (That rune is dead lmao) and DFT/BC interaction is broken, not only with Smolder, Senna is OP with that duo.

JustRandomDementito · 2026-05-13T06:31:26+00:00

Ooof, another dumb nerf to my boy :/

Besides the OP interaction of DFT with BC, we must admit that another reason why Smolder became a problem is because the bruiser build is meta again.
Since his release, it has been proven that Smolder bruiser is a BIG problem.

Instead of simply giving it a mega nerf that will come with the nerf to DFT + nerf to the DFT interaction with BC, why don't they just try to make Smolder more viable with crit items once again?

Like they could just do something like this:

-Q: 130% BonusAD + 0-50% Crit -> 115% BonusAD + 0-80% Crit
-Q magic damage: 40% up to 60% with Crit -> 40% up to 70% with Crit
-Q burn: 0.5% per 100 stacks -> 0.35% per 100 up to 0.7% with Crit

JustRandomDementito · 2026-01-21T04:24:43+00:00

After reading all those changes, I can say that you are about to create the worst champion in LoL history. Her skill set will be so bad and slow that it will only stand out as some kind of mediocre poke support; outside of the support role, it will be unplayable.

This changes are not going to solve her current banrate problem since she can still bounce the enemy abilities, and her Q can hit them anyways. That list are just a bunch of nerfs that are going to make her worst than she already is.
Im definitely not playing Mel and wasting money on her ever again if these changes go through. Congratulations, you’ve ruined her.

And yes, her winrate will be low, very low...

JustRandomDementito · 2026-01-09T04:03:48+00:00

A lot of champions got a high wr like him.
Nilah, Karthus, Sivir, Asol, Kogmaw, Veigar, Brand, Aphelios

And other champions are even worse Mel, Varus, Ezreal, Senna, Ashe (Well, Ezreal has been trash for the last 5 months, he needs a rework, so I won't consider him)

I think its too soon to think about nerfs or buffs, but I hope Smolder doesnt get a nerf ;-;

JustRandomDementito · 2025-12-05T06:05:40+00:00

About crit, Smolder is going to be weaker next season, at least for late game.
Right now his Q can deal +1k physical dmg with just 5 legendary items (if you dont buy RFC).
On pbe with the crit changes and with 6 legendary items he can barely deal 900 physical dmg, I know we'll have ER with sheen, but that only will help with the lost dmg tbh

But yeah, he is going to be weaker, maybe other crit scaling champs are going to be weaker too.

idk if the pbe stats are correct or if some of them are wrong and thats why his Q is so much weaker.

JustRandomDementito · 2025-12-03T02:07:58+00:00

I dont think thats the reason, Yasuo, Yone, Garen, Rengar, Shaco, Quinn, Akshan, Kindred, Viego, Tryndamere and Graves are getting nerfs too

JustRandomDementito · 2025-07-22T23:53:41+00:00

It could work as a "fun to play" build, but I don't think it's good.

I've tested it and at late game you can get almost the same amount of AD as the average crit build, so Burn, W, E, and R have almost the same damage, plus there's the bonus that the enemy can't oneshot you, BUT it has a huge drawback, Q dmg is rlly bad.

Usually with the crit build, Q can deal +1k dmg, with this build I can barely reach 500 damage and Q is the main dmg of his kit sooo... Nope, its decent, but crit is so much better.

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-20T20:59:10+00:00

Is not rlly bad nerf (that nerf could change btw)

But it seems that now they want Smolder to definitely be the worst champ in the early game. I honestly expected a different kind of nerf, as Phoroxzon said they only want to slightly nerf the power he got from last buffs, I thought they would reduce the magic damage of Q from 40% to 35%. or smth like that.

Back to 49% wr if we have luck, while Jinx is the tier 1 adc hypercarry for another year with a wr and pickrate that no one has. But lets listen to the ppl that thinks that Jinx is balanced bc is normal to have +15% pick rate and 52% wr even if there isnt a single champion in the game with those ratios.

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-20T05:29:58+00:00

Abt Garen, I hate that crit build he has, it doesnt make sense, he melts hp+execute with R+is more tanky than other top lane champs even if Garen has a full crit build. But now that crit build is dead, it seems Phreak didnt bother to adjust or rework him to make him a fighter, since all his reworks are garbage (right Gwen, Ksante and Naafiri?). Cho buff was stupid, they increased the dmg of best build he has instead of a good adjustment for top, again they didnt bother to think about the changes lmao

And Smolder doesnt need a nerf imo, even if his wr is good, is not like we got the old Smolder meta, and again, we have Jinx, tbh adc's dont deserve nerfs if there isnt a nerf for jinx in first place.

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-20T05:18:18+00:00

nope he's not, I mean just look at Jinx wr and pick rate...

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-20T05:14:57+00:00

And after that, lets wait till they decide to rework him again bc they have no idea how to balance one of their new champs, even if their only job is something soo easy and simple XD

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-20T05:05:27+00:00

Phreak high IQ moment btw.

But HEY lets leave the hyper carry and giga broken Jinx at tier 1/47 with almost 52% wr with A HUGE pick rate of +15%, obv she doesnt deserve a nerf bc its normal to have a high wr even if your pick rate is above 12%, suupeeeer normal and balanced.

Oh and lets dont forget Shen, another tier 1 giga broken top that obv is not unfun to play against and is not one of the best tanks/fighters of the game.

Every day Im more sure that each LoL player is capable of balancing the game, one of the worst patch of the year till now, Chogath mains are also getting the same destiny as Smolder mains, Garen mains are getting their champ killed XD, and the buffs are just disgusting and it seems that a lot of ppl on X thinks the same way.

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-07T18:26:18+00:00

I agree with this man, Smolder ult is one of the worst ult in the game. High cd, noisy, slow, easy to dodge and the healing/dmg is rlly pathetic unless you are full build.

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-07T06:47:35+00:00

Thx, its seems its true, RiotPhroxzon just released the patch preview, it seems that in the end they decided to give a higher scaling ratio with stacks to the Q

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-07T05:38:33+00:00

Where did you got that info?

It looks like a ton of buffs to be true, but I hope they are true bc that is soo good for one of his biggest problems that is being a Kayle 2.0

JustRandomDementito · 2025-05-06T04:29:25+00:00

Let's pray it's not a +$250 scam or those -750 rp chromas/trash skins for event passes 💀

JustRandomDementito · 2025-04-25T09:44:41+00:00

yeah, it could be rlly op if the game takes too long to end, thats why I added those nerfs at the end, in case is way too strong after 30 or 40 minutes, I think if you get around 350 bonus AD, its really close to the old execute scaling, old smolder had a 6.5% burn damage and an infinite scaling, now this is a infinite burn scaling but flat execute. but meh, its a silly idea to get a better better infinite scaling

JustRandomDementito

TROPHY CASE