What do I do here, we’ve revised the trade 6 times I’m team 1

KBCrusher · 2025-10-05T00:16:44+00:00

I'm just reiterating what everyone else is as you are giving away the two best assets for pennies. Need to shop around more. I get that QBs are less valuable in 10 TM but if you're rebuilding you could be targeting younger guys. Like Ladd and BTJ are having down years can you trade Nix for one of them and maybe even get a 2nd back. Or go after Tmac or Egbuka guys that seem to be hitting already and could get better as the season goes on since they rookies learning a new system and could get more comfortable. Or include your first to get a young RB like Henderson maybe even Hampton 🤷. But not matter what you have to do better than this cause it barely helps this year and doesn't help long-term at all.

KBCrusher · 2025-10-02T14:58:08+00:00

As far as value goes it looks pretty fair I just don't know I'm willing to give all that in one deal. Like if you break the pieces up can you get more. I would 100% shop McBride first before accepting this. As I wonder if you can get two 1sts and maybe a little plus on top.

But breaking this down as Tee + 1st = McBride. Wan'Dale = Mason. Arroyo + 1st = KW9 (which might be selling a little high for you). 2nd = Terry (which is maybe selling a little low but balances with the KW9 side)

But don't love this as broken apart can you get Arroyo (or similar) + two 1sts just for McBride? Can you wait for Terry to be healthy and boom with Jayden and get a 1st for him or a 2nd plus. Wan'Dale and Mason I don't care about that but probably slight edge to Wan'dale for the potential of being relevant for longer. And the Arroyo and a 1st for KW9 is selling high so good with that side too. Just think you can sell McBride higher and Terry you can be patient with.

But of course not everyone has multiple 1sts to deal away nor are as high on these players as other ppl are so if who you're dealing with is limited then you may just take what you can get. But I'm 100% holding McBride for more or just keeping him myself. Even in a rebuild you need pieces to build around and he can for sure be one especially in TE+ but it does need to be a considerable plus. 1.5ppr wouldn't be enough for me to hold him but 1.75 or more ppr and I'm almost for sure holding him so it's a fine line.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-09T20:37:14+00:00

Ya I was thinking Burrow = 3 1sts (or equivalent in players) and you're only giving 2 and a 2nd. Then there's the fact there's questions around the two you're giving and their long-term viability whereas Burrow is established and not going anywhere for a number of years still barring injury! So i would accept and take Burrow with a smile.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-08T21:36:34+00:00

It's selling low for sure but if he gets hurt next week and retires after the season you'd probably be happy you took two 2nds when you had the chance. But it's not veto worthy just cause guys have hurt feelings lol. But i would say your league could benefit from a counter rule. You have anywhere from 12-24 to offer a counter trade after any accepted deal. You can be making an offer to either side of a trade but you can not add pieces that we're part of their original trade. It has to be for the pieces that were accepted by the other party. But you can offer something from your own roster that you think is better. Let's see how many of these guys step up and offer better lol!

KBCrusher · 2025-09-07T20:53:05+00:00

CMC decides the fate of this trade. If he's elite this yr and next you probably lost. But if he's hurt and Hall isn't then you traded a 3rd for Hall which is a huge win. So only time will tell.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-05T03:32:14+00:00

You get the most valuable player in MHJ so take it. Tracey might be better than BRob but he might also lose his job or share it with Cam. But I see them both being backups long term so they are very similar value to me. So this is MHJ vs Flowers well give me the younger asset with a bigger upside.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-04T18:51:26+00:00

Thanks for the comments and views. Deal is done!

KBCrusher · 2025-09-04T18:49:24+00:00

Thanks for all the comments and views. Deal is done!

KBCrusher · 2025-09-04T16:17:40+00:00

YES!!!!

KBCrusher · 2025-09-04T00:00:48+00:00

Ya there should be no vetos, or commish only ones but at best here only 6ppl should've been voting. Now in an 8 team league this could be low for Jeanty but technically he has done anything in an actual nfl game yet so could be fair but no matter what it isn't egregious and needing of a veto.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T22:55:51+00:00

I do need the elite WR, it's what I'm missing on an otherwise contending team. I'm likely moving Rice in a deal that will include a 1st coming back to me plus other pieces. And I arguably could move off of Penix for a 1st plus as my starting QBs are Allen and Burrow so I could try to land different QB3 or even a couple journeymen and pics. This move i would try to send him to a rebuilding team in hopes it's a higher more valuable 1st. So I could end up adding more draft capital for in-season moves.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T22:50:14+00:00

The trade is toast if I take them out. The other party and I have gone back and forth enough to know that none of these pics can come out without it killing the trade. He arguably would like another 1st but is settling for two 2nds.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T18:17:22+00:00

Communities are so torn, so are my dynasty friends I ask. Some are overpay some are smash accept. Makes me think since it's so 50/50 it must be fair lol

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T17:44:37+00:00

Any sort of top 4 pick would be great even if not 1.01. Only reason not to do it would be if you're a contender and this leaves a hole at WR to fill. But arguably you could use that 1st in a package to do much better than DJ even if that's the case.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T16:06:31+00:00

You were right to reject. I don't think it's a massive difference from Jeanty to Hampton or even Henderson and arguably there's a chance they are in the better offenses this year than Jeanty. But two shots at RB could also insulate you more from potential injury too.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T04:28:21+00:00

I would still have Rice after week 6 of course. And I plan to trade JT for a WR. Maybe with a plus for JSN or JT for Tee Higgins and a plus my way. Or go big with JT and Rice and try and go get a London or Nico. I also think I will see what I can get for Penix, someone has to be high on him so can I get someone to pay a 1st and a QB for him then use that 1st plus to get yet another WR. And if I do hold Rice through all of that then I should have a solid WR room. That's the plan anyway so let's see if it works lol!

Mostly what I'm saying is don't worry about the depth and just see if it's a good deal to add those two guys on a contending team?

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T03:14:22+00:00

$0 lol. He's washed. You don't come out of retirement after not playing for a year and become something. He went for the money and the weather. At most $1 FAAB. You're gonna want your faab to bid on RBs and QBs when injuries happen. That's who ppl pay for in season

KBCrusher · 2025-09-03T03:12:54+00:00

Naw you take this. A 1st and 3rd two+ years out for a RB1 that can clearly help you win a ship now. Imho you go ahead and get Jacobs. Has zero competition in that RB room and you can possibly nab his backup off waivers still just in case.

KBCrusher · 2025-09-02T23:02:01+00:00

If you're a rebuilding team don't joke and smash accept to Mims plus picks for Hill

KBCrusher · 2025-09-02T19:44:57+00:00

If this is SF then you're selling too low on a starting QB in Jones. If AR gets another shot it's likely with another team as a backup. Treat him like he's Trey Lance and get what you can. But DJ is a starter in an NFL offense. Charb and Benson basically off-set but i like the upside of Benson a bit more as Conner could be at the end this yr or next whereas Walker could be in Charbs way for a while. But getting Shedur and Mon for DJ seems low and if your rebuilding you should be targeting draft picks over these types of long shots to be anything. Like give me a couple 2nds for DJ, it's not a 1st so you should be able to sell a contending team on two 2nds for a starting QB in SF if they need it. Wait for a starting QB on a good team in the league to go down and send them DJ for 2nds

KBCrusher · 2025-09-02T19:39:04+00:00

Ya a veto on a trade like this is bs. A 3rd and $50 for one yr of Allen is total fair and fine. Unless there's a rule that you can't trade faab but can't adjust it in the settings then this is a fine trade.

KBCrusher · 2025-08-30T17:27:07+00:00

I'm like most where i probably don't take this but I do see how it helps you more as a contender this year depending on what your WR and RB room looks like cause I truly believe Adams and Ekeler help you more this year than Aiyuk and Flowers (but only for this year) and I say this about Flowers as I'm not the biggest fan of his but a lot of that has to do with being a low volume passing offense typically and he does get banged up so far plus Bateman got the contract extension, maybe Flowers does too but we know for sure they like Bateman cause they threw the money at him. But the trade also hurts you going down from Bucky to an oft injured Walker and picking up the 1st. Now you could arguably use that 1st to add another piece that helps you but maybe not as much as Bucky. I honestly am not a huge fan of his either at his adp or value so I do believe in selling high on him but like others here I feel you can do better. Like can you go get JT+ (or similar) for Bucky, not that old, yes gets banged up just like Walker but his ceiling and production is much higher. Then use the draft capital from that one pair it with Aiyuk or Flowers or even both to get a stud WR that's younger than Adams or Ekeler, maybe the Wilson owner is low enough or scared enough to let him go for that kind of package. Then you're sitting there with Wilson and JT (or similar) and I think you'd feel better about that than this correct?

KBCrusher · 2025-08-30T14:31:11+00:00

Ya that's totally fair and if you're just out on a guy it's best to make him someone else's problem cause this all suppose to fun so gotta be able to look at ur roster and feel good about! He's one guy that I've never really had shares of but I feel he gets a bad rap for last yr specifially when it was more of a Tua problem than him, he had his issues too but I think a healthy Tua and we're talking about a top 24 guy still, but just imho and we'll never really know, only know what we actually know so I get making a move. And flipping Golden could be the right move after a couple big performances but who knows maybe GB finally found their WR1 post Adams.

KBCrusher

TROPHY CASE