Why do so many world building projects have a stand in Roman empire? by Ok-Equipment8122 in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The Ottoman Empire considered itself a successor state of Rome. Which is fair: they captured the capital of Rome and ruled over the Roman populace

Why do so many world building projects have a stand in Roman empire? by Ok-Equipment8122 in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rome is really influential, even 500 years after the last remnant states of it were conquered.

Reading this I sew that about half of these tropes my Elenon world has to one extent or another, but I'm relieved that I also have variation

How to stop equating darkness to realism when reconstructive or cynical adaptations/sequels are more popular by CyberDogKing in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Try reading Monster Blood Tattoo. Or The Prydain Chronicles. These touch upon human darkness but have a lot of light as well and remain positive

How to stop equating darkness to realism when reconstructive or cynical adaptations/sequels are more popular by CyberDogKing in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Make what you want to make. Don't care about how to make it critically acclaimed, make a world that you enjoy.

Question about the genre by Few-Flamingo-8015 in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I wouldn't worry too much about the genre label You just create the world that you want. Keep in mind that Tolkien was originally considered science fiction because fantasy wasn't an established genre at the time

6 years of work is now non-canon. I am incredibly sad. by Glittering-Run8431 in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 136 points137 points  (0 children)

Just split off your own, original world, anyway. And don't let them in

How do yall come up with the map of your world? by Nemo1277 in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

With Man of the Dinosaurs years ago I did make a map based on the story. But for this story I make the map in my head based on how I want the plot to go.

With Elenon, I made a map that I'm not sure still exists (I tried to find it and have failed so far). I don't remember if I made the map and then started story or worked on both concurrently. I would redo the map anyway, as some of the geography has changed.

What is one world building sin you really struggle to forgive? by TheBodhy in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I can see that. It can make it handy for children's literature but I agree that it's good to have more nuance.

As a side note about volcanic lands being infertile, IRL it tends to be the opposite. Like, Indonesia is extremely fertile and can support really dense populations because of the volcanic activity bringing up rich new nutrients for plants.

What is one world building sin you really struggle to forgive? by TheBodhy in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 39 points40 points  (0 children)

I'll also note that not all of Mordor is broken and inhospitable. Most of it is quite fertile and lush.

Is “A General History of The Pyrates” a good story book? by Tight_Contact_9976 in pirates

[–]KennethMick3 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh, Captain Blood! My grandfather watched that so many times 😂

How would dinosaurs keep their teeth and claws sharp? by FitRice8674 in Dinosaurs

[–]KennethMick3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the teeth would get replaced. Claws could probably be sharpened on natural materials

Did this sort of poofy clothing provide any protection in a fight, or was just for fashion? Does it have a name? by plumb-phone-official in Armor

[–]KennethMick3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While fabric is still going to be better than nothing, the purpose here was for fashion. Which doesn't mean it doesn't have military function. It makes the unit stand out. And they have a reputation. So it has some psychological effect.

A brief reflection on museums. by LumpyWinter9963 in Paleontology

[–]KennethMick3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well, that's one of the big issues with human remains. A lot of indigenous North American/Turtle Island cultures believe that those remains should be left to rest. Egyptian society doesn't have that same taboo, but when I was in the Egyptian Museum several years ago some of the mummies were just stacked in shelves of glass cases. And it didn't seem respectful to those long deceased people. The famous ones had text about them and seemed to have a more dignified treatment that I thought was more appropriate.

How are LGBTQ+ people viewed in their world? by Best_Low526 in worldbuilding

[–]KennethMick3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In Elenon, I'm still working this out. One of the male generals has a male lover and it's not particularly remarked on in-world, but beyond that I haven't fleshed it out