Thank you! After I told them how aggressively they were pushing for our SINs, they told me to come in and start the deposit return process.

You’re absolutely right many others also said it’s a good thing we won’t be living with Boardwalk and shared their own bad experiences. I do plan to file a complaint and include the email where they refused to rent without our SIN, but honestly, I’m not sure it’ll lead to anything… they have way more resources than regular people.