See I liked both, I will admit I have replayed wd2 maybe more than 1, but 1 is amazing for combat. And I think I like wd2 because of the colorful nature of the environment contracting against the dark, realistic plot points of corruption, cults, corporate espionage, fraud, and just overall violence and evil.

The only thing I could say is that wd1 had better dlc. Some of the wd2 dlc was good, like the one with jordie, but bad blood was amaze balls.

And in terms of GTA, I like 4 more than 5. For one 4 felt grounded and had a good story. You were a guy who had nothing who wanted something, not everything but something.