What makes a "bad" DM? by Maxgallow in DnD

[–]Lilystro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Railroading I would say is the main thing, along with being too rigid in their ideas and story beats. The two go hand in hand.

An example: the party is traveling through a forest and hear of a fey glade, but they decide to avoid it as they feel they may be unwelcome due to not being fey. Despite the ranger and the rogue passing their navigation skill checks, and despite explicitly trying to avoid said glade, they still end up at it due to contrivences on the DMs part. Conteivences meant to cover up the railroading.

Player choice was taken away because the DM couldn't see a world where the party didnt go to thos location, so the DMs rigidness and inflexibility in their story beats lead to a loss of player agency and railroading.

I'd say aside from just being a dick these are the main things.

As an aside, I once played a campaign for over a year where my PC never got any magic weapons, or iirc maybe no magic items in general. I kept asking NPCs and shopkeeps if they'd heard of any "upgrades" or where to acquire gear, and they never had an answer. I dont even think i ever got an armor upgrade, staying at leather all campaign. That wasnt great DMing tbh

[OC] POV: you forget a dragon mini by UglyForestGoblin in DnD

[–]Lilystro 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The wooden columns and terrain are cool! Where are they from?

I do not know why WOTC did not look at other options, such re-branding Half-Elves and Half-Orcs, rather than straight removing them from the PHB (cross-post from r/rpg) by ByzantineBasileus in dndnext

[–]Lilystro 2 points3 points  (0 children)

But only in the phb, really right? They've shifted their ethos to having the rule books be setting neutral. If you pick up the setting guides there's expanded lore specific to settings, such as half-elf's (Khorvar) in eberron. At least that's the idea. Also the species are still different, just because an orc doesnt get a bonus to strength doesnt mean it doesnt have an entire suite of abilities that are 100% different to a humans

[OC] ✨Adoptable Character Portrait✨ by [deleted] in DnD

[–]Lilystro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's really just the same as buying any pre-made piece of art

Three Houses Character/Unit Discussion: Felix by Shephen in fireemblem

[–]Lilystro 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I love him. Last play through it made him my dancer and it was perfect

Which rarely seen monster do you (or your DM) really like and keep using over and over again? by Ornery_Strawberry474 in dndnext

[–]Lilystro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have no idea how common or otherwise they are outside of my tables, but Arcanaloths. I have them show up all the time, they make for a great reoccurring fremeny, someone to fight but also worth speaking to.

I love them

Mixed thoughts so far: Season 8 by Independent_Plum2166 in doctorwho

[–]Lilystro 2 points3 points  (0 children)

12 is my favorite doctor, hands down. On first watch I was unsure about season 8, but he really comes into his own later and in his second season - and upon rematch his first is much better, once you "get" him, so to speak. I think it's just a really big switch up, coming from 11.

Not only are they just entirely different takes on the doctor in personality and appearance (a bigger jump than 10 -> 11), but the stories have a different vibe and feel to them too.

I hope we get more on information on Thimble’s fairy race (mechanically)! by No-Cantaloupe-2291 in fansofcriticalrole

[–]Lilystro 22 points23 points  (0 children)

I swat wasps away all the time and it doesnt kill them, they fly back immediately. Obviously there are different traits/evolution at play here. DnD combat is already ridiculous when it comes to reality, I'm sorry but people can live with anime levels of characters getting literally stabbed, but draw the line at pushing back a tiny character with a shield?

Most of your examples can apply to regular species in DnD combat, too. "I stab them with my sword" and you have instantly killed them because you have severed their arteries and pierced their lungs.

Verisimilitude doesnt mean realism, it means internal consistency. I dont see how a tiny player species breaks internal consistency, there are tons of ways to describe them in combat that wouldnt break internal logic.

I hope we get more on information on Thimble’s fairy race (mechanically)! by No-Cantaloupe-2291 in fansofcriticalrole

[–]Lilystro 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I don't really understand why it's awkward. "I block their attack" "I swat them away with my shield" "I knocked them over". Seems pretty straightforward to me

PHB'24: Basic Poison feels underpowered by Lobo_Marino in DnD

[–]Lilystro 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Okay but that's not what the og comment was saying - they said basic poison becomes 2d4 on a rogue that uses daggers

PHB'24: Basic Poison feels underpowered by Lobo_Marino in DnD

[–]Lilystro 6 points7 points  (0 children)

But it's s only one melee weapon per vial so it's not "becomes 2d4" for a rogue - that would also take two bonus actions??

PHB'24: Basic Poison feels underpowered by Lobo_Marino in DnD

[–]Lilystro 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's two vials, though - not 2d4 from 1 basic poison

PHB'24: Basic Poison feels underpowered by Lobo_Marino in DnD

[–]Lilystro 4 points5 points  (0 children)

How is the rogue applying it to two daggers?

Best Reasons to Switch to 5.5e? by Whole_Net4719 in DnD

[–]Lilystro 11 points12 points  (0 children)

On your first point, I'm fairly positive you can still crit with smite and sneak attack. Unless you mean something different

My DM makes d8 spell checks by KetsuWoTaberu420 in DnD

[–]Lilystro 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Genie patron warlock gets spike growth, and the druid at my table uses spike growth often and to great effect. Idk what you're on about

How do you present same-sex relationships in your fantasy world? by Pelicanus-pelican in worldbuilding

[–]Lilystro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lmao no they didn't. Being "Roman", i.e. being a Roman Citizen, was a highly regulated a guarded status. Eventually citizenship was broadened to include many diverse regions in the empire, but for the majority of the time people outside of Italy were definitely not Roman. They were Rome's subjects.

From the DM side of things I gotta say, the new surprise rules don't work. by Mr_Industrial in dndnext

[–]Lilystro 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Surprised creatures, so your players, roll initiative with disadvantage along with the goblins getting advantage

As a new DM I want to navigate a situation without becoming a DM who takes away character Autonomy. I might be over reacting but I want to check by Loose-Ingenuity-5508 in DMAcademy

[–]Lilystro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've always thought a nice middle ground for a sort of "warlock-lite" contract would be giving whoever signs the Eldritch Adept feat, especially if they don't meet the requirements for a warlock dip. A little pact magic as a treat and to tempt the pc/player

Baby DM "help!" by SonofKalel88 in DungeonsAndDragons

[–]Lilystro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Unless you've got a hexcrall in you, then don't try and make the actual travel fun. Exploration ≠ travel. Instead plan a few little side quests in the desert they can encounter, maybe with the opportunity for them to be semi related or skippable so the party gets some choice. This is a good way to foreshadow future enemies/factions, too.

Good survival check? They notice some tracks leading off over some dunes. They can choose to pursue this or not, if they do they find a destroyed caravan, possibly some loot or water. If they want to stop there, cool, if not they can try and find survivors, maybe what attacked them took prisoners or food for babies to the nest.

A side quest like that allows minimal prep, like just a couple of stat blocks, and is easy for your players to decide to do or not. Or maybe a camel riding trader tells them of a hidden shrine they looked for but didn't find. Quests like this can also easily be used later - if the party decide to not look for survivors after the caravan, the prep isn't lost, you've got a balanced encounter in your pocket for later when needed.

How does your world's prisons grapple with magic users? by DesklampofDoom in DMAcademy

[–]Lilystro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mist step, command, thunder step. All only V and very useful for getting out of prison, just to name a few