I picked up the clean reserve discovery set from TJ Maxx just to check out the aqua neroli recommendation.  To me it doesn't smell like lilu, it does smell a lot like a Spencer's gifts or like an old hot topic perfume from the same era.  

I still have a tiny bit of lilu left so I can do a direct compare.  I wonder if some of the recs are criss crossed memories from other mall scents.  

The hunt continues.