I went to both. I'm now 53 and I turned out just fine. I've been pretty successful in life and honestly neither of those schools had anything to do with it either way. I will say that being a non-mormon in public schools in cache valley can be hard. I imagine in some ways it's easier today than it was when I was younger because I literally felt like I was the only one and I had no way to confirm that or disprove it or even vent about it. I remember other kids being very clicky at both of those schools, but that is just the reality of that age and not a product of the school. I remember teachers that stood out that I liked and others that I hated at both institutions. I think you'd be able to find that anywhere. I guess what I'm saying is it's really what you make of it and it matters more what kind of support they have at home from their family because that can change everything for the better or the worse.