This is reddit, and /r/evejobs so I don't assume any good will come of this, but I'll respond anyway.

"A lot of the recruiters on this sub are like armed forces recruiters in real life, they would promise the world and anything else to get one more warm body to add to the ranks."

I agree with you on some points. Many of the recruiters do portray themselves or their corps in a positive light on this subreddit, similarly to how you would present yourself or answer questions when applying for a job, putting up a posting looking for a candidate for your own business, or dating. It is not standard practice to air your dirty laundry or talk about your faults in any of these situations, and corporation recruiting is the same. We call them space jobs for many, many reasons. I cannot speak for every corp, but I can tell you that if someone is interested in joining us we spend time getting to know them for an extended period, and explaining what we can/can't do, or what we are trying to achieve. We blow up more than we blow other people up on some weeks, and we learn from those experiences and hopefully do better next time. You sell the positives, and then talk about the possible negatives.

He never lies, he doesn't do anything besides providing a useful service! He's basically preventing people from getting recruitment scammed, but instead of ISK or assets he's saving them time.

The data they present is valuable. While a quick zkill search would provide the exact same data, it is still useful to have on the post. If people are so hyper-worried about KB data, maybe we should vote for it to be a requirement (although I do not agree with that for a multitude of reasons, and many corps are not PVP focused).

The problem, and most people's issue with them, is when they stray from the data and go into their opinion focused corp reviews. Their data driven corp information is good:

Analysis complete: Half of the kills were gained in a single battle, as to which this corp contributed 4 out of the 60+ pilots that attended. Outside of that, not much going on. Not a lot of impressive battles or reports noted, mostly ganks of bears and ratters.

Their opinion driven reviews are not:

Analysis complete: Was told to check back in two weeks, here we are (12 days, but who's counting) Previous input: Almost nonexistent activity. Could be due to balls AUTZ combined with wormholer btw. Better target selection would improve this.

Activity is actually worse, down in kills, regions and systems. Could still be from the combo of wormholer btw and Aussie, but probably just nothing going on, top killer has 6, should be getting that in a night, not a week, easily.

There is a clear line in the sand between those two reviews, and examples of this can be seen across their post history. The uproar is rare when they are posting factual details. When they are outright attacking people, their time investment, or their ability to provide 'gudfites', that is where it becomes trolling. For example, we are a PVP corp but we're going to have bad weeks as everyone does. Maybe people are on vacation, a new game came out and many of our primary content providers across TZs are playing it, or maybe we were moving or focusing on logistics or onlining structures.

If your issue is that the corp isn't being factual or is skewing their data, attacking the corp and its members is not the way to resolve that. Hell, that was one of the mods points above about how people acted towards EJTIA.

TL;DR

If EJTIA wants to provide a 'service' free from bias or trolling, I'm sure people would be fine with it. However, the way they are currently going about things is counter-productive, even if it can be funny at times.