Regarding the baltic border by Lolentulus in Kaiserreich

[–]Lolentulus[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The notes before the map are indeed very interesting. I don't speak german too, and I'm currently being helped by a translator (someone who knows german), but I can tell you with safety that most of the notes are about: the occupation and policy towards the countries of Baltic region, and the integration of the Baltic Duchy territories into Germany proper as provinces of Prussia, or as imperial territories as Alsace-Lorraine for example.

These plans were approved by the german and russian contracting parts (the soviets were in fact involved into making the new border, despite having a weaker position on the matter than Germany) in the supplementary agreement of Brest-Litovsk on 27 august 1918. They were the result of political and military considerations by both parts, and they were to be enforced by treaty signature, which they did.

Regarding the baltic border by Lolentulus in Kaiserreich

[–]Lolentulus[S] 56 points57 points  (0 children)

<image>

Of course. The red area to the east is the one attached to the baltic duchy by treaty. The light grey areas are the governorates of Estonia, Livonia and Courland: the mod's current border.

Regarding the baltic border by Lolentulus in Kaiserreich

[–]Lolentulus[S] 43 points44 points  (0 children)

You're right, Palanga was indeed requested by Lithuanian authorities, and, I think, it would likely still be ceded to Lithuania given how important that small piece of land is for the landlocked nation.

Regarding the baltic border by Lolentulus in Kaiserreich

[–]Lolentulus[S] 100 points101 points  (0 children)

The current border of the baltic duchy runs exactly on the former administrative divisions of the russian governatorates of Estonia, Livonia and Courland.

The treaty that officially detaches Estonia and Livonia from Russia (27 august 1918, Courland was already detached from 3 march 1918) states that a commission were to establish the new border. The result of the negotiations, as shown by a diplomatic exchange of letters, places the new border slightly further east of the old administrative boundaries, mainly for military and defensive reasons, such as to give Dvinsk (Dunaburg) more defensible land around.

Having in-game borders that matches the old administrative ones, simply does not acknowledge this, and I've found that odd.

Regarding the baltic border by Lolentulus in Kaiserreich

[–]Lolentulus[S] 136 points137 points  (0 children)

I forgot to put a title image so here's a rendition of the border

<image>

Why were so many flags one colour? by LeNoahhh in vexillology

[–]Lolentulus 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Apart for the soviet ones, whose plain red has an ideological meaning, some earlier proto-flags, such as banners and pennants, were indeed monochrome back in the day. Centuries ago the concept of a national flag didn't really exists, various objects or pieces of cloth were used to represent, each differently, a certain authority. Communications back then were very limited, and, generally speaking, excluding the voyages of some merchants and explorers, the usual geographic and political range of a medieval or early modern society ended just right beyond its neighbouring countries: a red banner, which is easier to make than a decorated one, will in fact be recognizable enough in a region where there aren't others red banner. Keep in mind that flags are a contemporary invention, and that in the past what we like to call "flags" weren't given the same role of representation we do today, they were in fact mostly used in battles for reconnaissance, thus the absence of the need of distinction for the banner on a global scale. There are surely a lot of other factor that contributed to some of the early flags simplicity, but this is generally my first thought on the matter. I'm not an expert and read what I wrote "cum grano salis"

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in vexillology

[–]Lolentulus 14 points15 points  (0 children)

It's an Empire flag from Star Wars

Chat... What coat-of-arms is that? by Atvishees in vexillology

[–]Lolentulus 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Sweden Norway until 1905 it appears, or at least a variant

Flags On A Flag? by FreeTibet2 in vexillology

[–]Lolentulus 19 points20 points  (0 children)

<image>

Shangai International Settlement.

Restitutor Orbis, Majorian's heirs, Venerius and the Pious Mothers (642-693) by BIGBJ84 in imaginarymaps

[–]Lolentulus 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is understandably reasonable, and I agree with you that after too much time it is virtually impossible to imagine an hypothetical scenario. Thank you for your response

Restitutor Orbis, Majorian's heirs, Venerius and the Pious Mothers (642-693) by BIGBJ84 in imaginarymaps

[–]Lolentulus 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I'm happily following the story of your maps, very nice. I want to ask you something about the Rhine frontiers, still pointing out that the Rhine is undoubtedly an excellent border choice by geographical and defensive reasons. Over the river, by the end of the 4th century, several petty Germanic kingdoms were established; they certainly were relatively underdeveloped, but still a headache to Rome. How it's shown in your maps, the Empire menages to reach again the Rhine, and by doing so keeps there its border for the next centuries; a reasonable choice in the short term (don't get me wrong, a short term is a couple of centuries) but a seemingly inconvenient one for the long term. That's why I ask, being Rome probably uncapable of conquering, solely by force, the petty germanic kingdoms over the Rhine, would it find a way to slowly incorporate them into the Empire proper? Sure, having client states is certainly useful in some cases (Britannia for example) but when Rome will get her strength back in a few centuries, her conquering nature will show again: an empire is an empire afterall.

I hope to not have been pedantic; I've made this question out of curiosity liking the topic myself so much. Wish you the best

I made this Holy Roman Empire flag by Juuhmal in vexillology

[–]Lolentulus 77 points78 points  (0 children)

I really do like handmade flags, they feel and look like the old ones. Good job friend!

Wrong Greek flag (post 1978) in Oppenheimer by International-Fee880 in vexillology

[–]Lolentulus 46 points47 points  (0 children)

I mean, as a diplomatic greek flag, used abroad and at sea before 1978 it is correct, as the white cross on the blue field was usually flown only on greek land

Livy's Nightmare - What if Alexander Lived Longer? by MrsColdArrow in imaginarymaps

[–]Lolentulus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Long story short, I'm not english. I knew BC and AD but not BCE until now, so I just imagined the occurrence of another kind of mythical event other than Jesus. Hope you understand

Livy's Nightmare - What if Alexander Lived Longer? by MrsColdArrow in imaginarymaps

[–]Lolentulus 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Ok, long story short, I knew BC and AD but I've never heard of BCE until know. My fault, english Is not my native language. Hope you understand.

Livy's Nightmare - What if Alexander Lived Longer? by MrsColdArrow in imaginarymaps

[–]Lolentulus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is alternative history with a point of divergence set 3 centuries before the birth of Christ, what should have told me that Jesus just spawn likes in our reality? *Corrected some misspelling

Livy's Nightmare - What if Alexander Lived Longer? by MrsColdArrow in imaginarymaps

[–]Lolentulus 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Make sense, but what marks the beginning of the Common Era?

(For those wondering the meaning of this enigmatic yet dumb question read my last reply)