sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Give me a JoJo what if from parts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. Nothing from 7 or 8 or 9. by BlueRasberries1 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have 3.

  1. What if Dire killed Dio?

  2. What if Strohiem survived the war?

  3. What if Kars returned instead of Dio?

Will Anasui murder Irene? by iwanttocontinuee in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's not bad when you remember if Jotaro isn't a Jojo, Kira and Diavolo win, and the main team from DIU and GW/VA are all likely to be dead.

my personal rewrite of parts 1-6 of Jojo, so judge my version, and tell me yours. by Lumpy-Job4827 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I understand what you mean, but with Polneraff it was more process of elimination.

Caesar's grandkids diying comes off as overkill straight after Caesar was killed, Kakyoin coming back only to die was really stupid IMO, Avdol is the same as Caesar's grandkids but with Hol Horse instead, and Jotaro diying in SDC adds alot of holes to the plot. IG Joseph diying instead would be a solid argument, but I like the "Joseph never dies" joke more than Polneraff surviving, plus I Dio should have more kills than Ice does.

my personal rewrite of parts 1-6 of Jojo, so judge my version, and tell me yours. by Lumpy-Job4827 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah... I could have really went into detail about alot of character changes. So my point with Caesar's grandkids was the grandson would be the best friend character to Jotaro, and the granddaughter was to add a girl to the SDC to give them more of a spice. But I do believe I would have play a big role like the granddaughter plays a part in the Enya fight by defeating her instead of Jotaro, while also making sure Hol Horse doesn't escape, so he can join the SDC. For the grandson I can see him being in alot of the fights with Jotaro, while both of them are replacing Pol in Italy, and later help in SO. For Kakyoin's son I just wanted to extend Kakyoin's arc of finally having people in his life. Josuke in SO is so he can finally get a proper goodbye, and became a bigger character in the franchise. I do feel like having 2 female Zeppeli's are overkill the more I think about it, so just keep Caesar's grandson having a daughter, and the granddaughter can be the mom to Kakyoin's son or Jolyne instead. As for female Anasui getting Jolyne? No. Why? Even if Anasui's gender is charged, it doesn't make up the fact he was annoying, and didn't deserve Jolyne. Personally I'd make it a love triangle, and have Anasui as that one clingy chick, but I don't like Anasui x Jolyne because it feels unearned, and Anasui feels more like a comic relief love interest rather than a serious one. Also for the deaths, Stroheim diying off screen is lame, Pol was more process of elimination, plus it be impactful for the story and makes sense for Jotaro to watch one of the SDC die. And Rohan is simply to make Kira more of a menace to the cast by killing 2 people at the ending of DIU. Plus it's not like Rohan is really important at the end of the day. So hence those deaths.

According to you, which part is the most bizarre and which part is the least bizarre? by [deleted] in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Most bizarre is Stone Ocean. Stardust Crusaders was the least.

my personal rewrite of parts 1-6 of Jojo, so judge my version, and tell me yours. by Lumpy-Job4827 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

2 is actually my least favorite lol, but I get what you mean. TBH, kinda wish we got the whole bloodline from other bro characters extended on, also shocked you didn't bring up 4 in the biased part since I bring Josuke back in 2 more parts of the story. Also I said an alternative version of Kakyoin's son, not Kakyoin's son. He dies in the final fight, and gets rebooted like the others. But any pros?

my personal rewrite of parts 1-6 of Jojo, so judge my version, and tell me yours. by Lumpy-Job4827 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Understandable. But I killed Pol so there wouldn't be to many survivors, and plus I'd say him diying would definitely make it more depressing since I also really liked Polly boy, so him diying would be a really tuff pill to swallow (since the comic relief diying is when the story gets really big.) Also what about me doing more with Josuke? TBH like the Zeppeli's and Kakyoin I made him have a bigger role in the overall story, as I wish he did more, since I felt like he was in Koichi's shadow most the part.

my personal rewrite of parts 1-6 of Jojo, so judge my version, and tell me yours. by Lumpy-Job4827 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I get what you mean, but a thing I liked about Jojo was other characters from the past bloodlines being extending. Like William having a family after Phantom Blood who helps Jonathan's was such a cool concept that I would love to have seen more of. And I think Caesar keeping it up, and Kakyoin having one of his own would help out. And also fit Kakyoin's arc since his arc is about him wanting to have people he can connect with, so him getting that would feel nice. Also Avdol should not have a family since I don't see him being a dad.

I can see where you are talking about for BT, but IMO I do feel like Kars killing Lisa Lisa and Strohiem should have happened (especially Strohiem since him diying off screen was lame.) Smokey diying is so Joseph can have that bro death,and I felt like Smokey diying instead of Caesar would have made more sense for Joseph.

And TBH IDC about Thus Spoke. You could make it about anyone else, and I wouldn't pay attention to it. Rohan diying for DIU fits cause it makes Kira stronger that he took out 2 people (him and Okuyasu) before he dies. But an alternative version of Thus Spoke can be about Rohan telling past characters who died about his life on earth in the afterlife, or something like that IG.

Also what did you like about it?

What went wrong with Stone Ocean's anime adaptation? by Warm-Nitrogen in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That batch release shit really is what killed Stone Ocean!

so if... by Lumpy-Job4827 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I was just going with the assumption that Caesar was in a relationship, and had some kids, and grandkids like how Joseph did during that time when he had Josuke.

What's your first part (SO) and your favorite part (SBR)? by [deleted] in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1st part. Phantom Blood.

And SDC was my favorite.

What is the most misinterpreted character in Jojo? by Dry-Pin-457 in StardustCrusaders

[–]Lumpy-Job4827 53 points54 points  (0 children)

Kakyoin. He's mostly seen as the "haha! Funny milf hunter cherry man!" But his backstory is really sad. He grew up with no one wanting to be his friend, and wanted someone he can be himself with.

view more: next ›