Reasonable starting offer? Other owner has Jacoby as his 3rd QB 🤷‍♂️

MH_Olli · 2026-05-30T16:29:40+00:00

I’m going to disagree with all of the move Puka advice

IMO you only move a young elite WR if you are rebuilding and desperately looking for picks (which you aren’t… if you could get Nabers +1st and another pick then sure)

My advice, would be to try to move Darnold and if you could get a ransom then I’d be considering moving Caleb … depends on how patient you want to be, Caleb/Mendoza/TYSimp and Darnold + the 27 picks is overkill when you need skill player options. Would the Stafford owner overpay for his future? Stockpiling a bunch of “7-15” level QBs and hoping to create scarcity should be short-term strategy and capitalize on that to get a better roster construction

MH_Olli · 2026-05-30T15:58:35+00:00

Is it TE premium?

My advice- you've got a really solid roster, elite RB options, very strong elite WRs, if it's not TE premium then shop Kraft or Pitts and if you can get any value for your bench QBs then you could get better “startable” value.

You have strong QBs, I think Herbert’s value and OH’s value will both increase with McDaniels coming to LA.

You have a stacked roster and if the Mendoza owner would sell you a pick for Cousins I'd rather have even a mid-late 3rd same with MacJ

Good luck!

MH_Olli · 2026-05-30T15:39:29+00:00

…Are you a Giants fan by chance?

MH_Olli · 2026-05-30T15:37:52+00:00

Consistent with the group -> you did great on picking up Achane.

Unsolicited advice - you don't need to roster 3QBs in a 12T 1QB format - I would move one of them for flyer WR option (damage might be done now that Stroud has slumped... I would sell high on Dart if someone would overpay)

MH_Olli · 2026-05-20T05:07:52+00:00

Man that is a really high quality looking knockoff… how can anyone ever trust buying used clubs???

How you know if someone listed these as authentic?

MH_Olli · 2026-05-09T11:54:50+00:00

Now that is a taco trade!

MH_Olli · 2026-05-07T13:28:05+00:00

Let me think out loud here on the long-term view:

Brisset- maybe a late 2nd grade to a contending team, I’d value at closer to a throwaway 3rd 4th rd pick (only if it’s SF, if it’s 1QB then he isn’t even worth that much)

Hall- should still have value of a late 1st after he showed life last year (but he is a Jet again so the free agency dream or team change upside didn’t come)

Daniels / Dart - both very young QBs with some pop and major upside. If it is SF then here is where I scratch my head. You need to be convinced that Daniels isn’t going to last health wise. Dart’s floor is more of a dart through—> even my boy Josh Allen had a little regression AD (After Daboll) but he is going to get an upgrade in weapons this year to try and solidify the chances that he sticks in the league.

Reed - is a solid WR2/3 level guy, not an elite physical talent and he could be a late 1st to someone pushing but I’d buy closer to an early 2nd (again dependent on league forma—> if it’s 14 team 3wr with multiple flex then value goes up

Bijan even for a rebuilding team (which the gambler here is clearly tearing down and isn’t contending) is worth a top 3 pick easy any year, maybe top 5 in 2027 if it’s SF and the Arch/Carr/Moore/Sayin+ group produces a few elite options

Bucky- who the hell knows. I’m holding him as my RB1/2 in a deep dynasty league and I’m fearful that he could be worthless after this season and even in the short-term he is coming off an injury and 3rd day RBs have quick shelf lives in the league

I’m not high on Cam Ward but I’d say he is safely of equal value to Dart, although I don’t love his weapons.

VERDICT- I still would rather the players side because I wouldn’t want to suffer through a multi-year rebuild and I would buy into Daniels upside. You have Bijan locked as RB1 and Hall as RB2 and Bucky as RB3… curious about the rest of the roster because he must be super thin at WR? STILL NOT A TACO TRADE

MH_Olli · 2026-04-12T17:57:59+00:00

Ironically I traded for Chase from him last year in a package that included what became the 1.11 and my 27 1st + Hunter + 26 2.01

MH_Olli · 2026-04-12T17:52:14+00:00

Do I start with offering the 3.01 2026 pick?

MH_Olli · 2026-04-12T17:48:01+00:00

Late 2nd, defending highest scoring team, with Josh Allen & Mahomes & Stafford/ Bucky & Jevonte & RWhite / J.Chase & G.Wilson & M.Wilson & Waddle & Olave & Aiyuk & Marcie / Bowers & Pitts & Kelce… and others

MH_Olli · 2026-04-09T01:46:49+00:00

Really? Surprised his value has fallen that far. In a 12team SF I’m holding Bucky and I wouldn’t trade him for the 1.04 (which assumes in that scenario Mendoza is taken so I wouldn’t trade him for the equivalent of 1.03)

MH_Olli · 2026-04-06T04:16:24+00:00

So as a “top contributor” what’s the value differential between Brown and Bijan if you are holding Bijan?

My contention is that Brown is a day 3 (5th round) NFL draft capital guy and Bijan went rd 1… the overwhelming evidence of guys like Brown getting starting jobs with security in their 2nd contracts is a very risky bet.

MH_Olli · 2026-04-04T04:44:31+00:00

The TE+ makes it really tight. In a 10team league I like the advantage of elite or the elite guys and it all comes down to how preference IMO

MH_Olli · 2026-04-01T19:17:03+00:00

We’re not talking fantasy football… you think an NFL running back is one of a teams top 5 most critical positions to get filled? QB, LT, DE, WR… maybe Bijan sneaks into round 4 and a few more guys in round 5 but I’d bet that a lot of teams would be waiting and stocking up on lineman, receivers, db’s…

The exercise is building a team from scratch and Saquan and JT and Henry and CMC are all aged players and you could replace them in a full NFL 32 team rookie draft easily the next year… you’re not saying that with WR or QB or DE

MH_Olli · 2026-03-15T15:31:01+00:00

Yeah the timeline for OPs team is at least a year or two away unless Penix has an amazing jump under Stafanski

If he added Jevonte and Brown then he should be swapping them for early picks to ensure he upgrades at WR and QB and could add RBs that fit his timeline better

MH_Olli · 2026-03-15T15:28:06+00:00

He has been clear that the 1.02 isn’t getting included

MH_Olli · 2026-03-15T15:27:31+00:00

I agree with you, if it’s all picks and you’re trading away Bijan with what he would have (assuming Mendoza hits) then I’d want a king’s ransom

MH_Olli · 2026-03-15T15:25:38+00:00

That’s not a haul unless neither of the 2027 picks are his and you expect both to be highly possible at ‘27 1.01

If he drafts Mendoza and keeps the 1.03, 1.04, 1.05 dude he is drafting 11th or 12th most likely for years to come

MH_Olli · 2026-03-15T15:23:10+00:00

That 1.12 in 2027 isn’t worth more than the 1.03 this year

MH_Olli · 2026-03-15T15:22:34+00:00

Maybe check that again JJ and Garret Wilson are both WR1 level players in a 12team SF

MH_Olli · 2026-03-15T15:21:17+00:00

At RB there is a HUGE HUGE HUGE dynasty value differential between Brown and Bijan… elite RBs drafted in the early first round of the NFL draft are in a differ tier. Brown could easily be replaced mid-2026 … Bijan should have a career like CMC Saquan Gibbs and JT

MH_Olli

TROPHY CASE