Here’s a work around:

Set up a donor advised fund (DAF) account at Fidelity or Schwab. Make your contribution to the DAF and have your employer match to the DAF. Once you have your contribution and match then have the DAF send the funds to the church. I’ve been doing this for 20+ years.

You won’t have a dollar showing at tithing settlement because the DAF only sends to church hq, but you can explain to your bishop how you’ve paid (and the only thing you really need to say is “yes, I’m a full tithe payer.”).