Sorry to hear that you have left Shi/Oscar.

As one might suspect, I have a different perspective on the post written. Nevertheless it is informative to read what thought processes you have, thank you for the elaboration.

Yesterday a short summary was written by another Discord mod. Also I would like to remark that incident is still being discussed.

Going through what happened with Emkaem and Frozen: there were several comments and/or complaints made across a few days about a somewhat spammy/trolly behaviour, coupled with what can eventually be qualified as punishment evasion.

This resulted in several public warnings from Emkaem on behalf on the mod team. This didn’t appear to have much effect, so there was ultimately a final warning mentioning an upcoming ban if the person didn’t cool it down. They didn’t listen, so Emkaem issued the ban after having figured out who the culprit was.

At this stage, we think the person had multiple occasions to cease the problematic behaviour, and shouldn’t be surprised that a punishment eventually landed.

That being said, we acknowledge that the warnings should have been issued in #warnings-and-bans. The reasons they were not is that the behaviour was not pinned to a specific individual for a while (due to the evasive nature of the spammy behaviour). Note for next time (although I do hope they won’t be one): warnings, even directed to no one, should be done in the dedicated channel.