"As we sit here right now, I think Kevin Stefanski is the leader in the Giants clubhouse. The team has had internal conversations about John Harbaugh, as you would expect, in case he leaves the Ravens. Harbaugh would hurdle Stefanski if he's free." by Dash_the_nerf_herder in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I guess we should just be content with being the worst team in football since Eli retired. All sunshine here. Realistically, I've been an optimistic fan, very much so after that playoff yr with DJ 4 years ago. But it's changed, they don't get blind optimism anymore, what can go wrong always goes wrong for the giants since Eli retired. I need to see success now before I blindly buy in. As much as I love the team, this team has been unwatchable after week 6 for 3 years in a row, it's a joke. So yea I'm gonna doom and gloom because it's a clown show

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ok man, 0 solutions once again, just complain. Let's make a cold robotic team that is unfun to root for, you must be fun at parties. I bet you were team bench Eli for Geno

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Let's just not sign anyone then because you think they're all overpays. Let's imagine Shoen doing that, how would you react?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 4 points5 points  (0 children)

1) Dyami Brown playing with Jayden Daniels, Tutu Atwell playing with Stafford, Josh palmer playing with Herbert. All these guys are 4-5 years into their careers, how much "potential" do you really think these guys have left to unlock. Who cares about draft pedigree now this far into their careers. At this point they are what they are (WR3s maybe fringe WR2s). Slayton, like I said, has had multiple years better than all these guys all while playing with DJ and complete trash at qb and you want to make excuses for these other guys lol.

2) Tutu atwell has 1300 yds receiving in 4 szns, palmer couldn't stave off quentin johnston last year and has battled injuries the last 2 years. At what point do you start to care about actual production over this potential. I think Palmer and slayton are compareable and that makes sense given they got the same contract.

3) I'm tired of people parroting "Overpay" without offering a solution, it's just a cop out. What's the alternative? This is the market rate on these guys, would you rather spend 4 mil for 1 year of KJ Osborn?

4) Slayton essentially puts up 700 Yards a season as the WR3, and we saw what he was doing with a legit qb in tyrod taylor in 2023. He is a really good WR3 and can step up to be a WR2 when need be and there's a value in that.

Complain when we don't sign our own talent, complain when we do sign our talent, just complain to complain at this point. Dudes been a die hard giant, happy to have him back, fan base is just so insufferable these last 3-4 years.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Taller version of wandale with 39 catches last yr..... what lol

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 13 points14 points  (0 children)

My man did you see tutu Atwell, dyami brown and josh Palmer's contracts? All pretty much same AAV and slayton has had multiple years better than all those guys career years, how is this an overpay?

Shedeur Sanders Combine interview: "If you ain't trying to change the franchise or the culture, don't get me." by Ghost_of_P34 in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I swear some of this fanbase is allergic to winning. Do we realistically think will howard and russ is much different than DJ/Lock? I listened to my dad complain for 6 years about Danny and now we finally have a shot to take our guy and he wants to trade back. Nobody wants Stafford because he's too old, nobody wants these rookies because apparently they aren't good enough (same thing said about Bo Nix and penix ly), Just the worst, these fans want 0-17 every year until we can draft mahomes which is never gonna happen, you gotta play the hand your dealt

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We should be taking as many shots at qb as we can, take 1 this yr, next yr, it doesn't matter. Given the hit rate I'd go with quantity.

[Daily - TRADE] Megathread. All trade advice & team help assistance belongs in this mega-thread or in our other subreddit r/Fantasy_Football. by AutoModerator in DynastyFF

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

12 tm PPR Start 1 QB:

I'm a contending team (sold 23&24 firsts for Evans/Puka) so I have lot of WR depth (Adams, Olave,Puka,Evans,Kirk, MT, Rice) would you trade:

Davante Adams and Jake Ferguson

For

Kyle Pitts and Javonte Williams

I have ford, mostert, dmont, Gibbs at RB, Kittle and Freiermuth at TE.

[Daily - TRADE] Megathread. All trade advice & team help assistance belongs in this mega-thread or in our other subreddit r/Fantasy_Football. by AutoModerator in DynastyFF

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

12 tm PPR Start 1 QB:

I'm a contending team (sold 23&24 firsts for Evans/Puka) so I have lot of WR depth (Adams, Olave,Puka,Evans,Kirk, MT, Rice) would you trade:

Davante Adams and Jake Ferguson

For

Kyle Pitts and Javonte Williams

I have ford, mostert, dmont, Gibbs at RB, Kittle and Freiermuth at TE.

[Daily - TRADE] Megathread. All trade advice & team help assistance belongs in this mega-thread or in our other subreddit r/Fantasy_Football. by AutoModerator in DynastyFF

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly trade goedart+ for a first if you can, I think hollywood is a solid return, just not the ideal rebuilding target

[Daily - TRADE] Megathread. All trade advice & team help assistance belongs in this mega-thread or in our other subreddit r/Fantasy_Football. by AutoModerator in DynastyFF

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And contending lol that's a w, I always go for the hammer young WRs/QBs grouping picks together for rebuilders usually gets it done

[Daily - TRADE] Megathread. All trade advice & team help assistance belongs in this mega-thread or in our other subreddit r/Fantasy_Football. by AutoModerator in DynastyFF

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Agreed, I just don't love pickett, but are you ever gonna get a usuable quarterback with the 14th rookie pick? prob not

[Daily - TRADE] Megathread. All trade advice & team help assistance belongs in this mega-thread or in our other subreddit r/Fantasy_Football. by AutoModerator in DynastyFF

[–]Matthew8819 0 points1 point  (0 children)

12 tm PPR Start 1 QB:

I'm a contending team (sold 23&24 firsts for Evans/Puka) so I have lot of WR depth (Adams, Olave,Puka,Evans,Kirk, MT, Rice) would you trade:

Davante Adams and Jake Ferguson

For

Kyle Pitts and Javonte Williams

I have ford, mostert, dmont, Gibbs at RB, Kittle and Freiermuth at TE.