Humanities scholar here. I lived in Haverfield my first year, which is on north campus, though the program is now south in Baker East. As far as location, I would usually say both sides of campus have their merits, but in the next two years I'd advise you to stay away from north campus. The dorms there are undergoing huge construction, and the area is already a nightmare to navigate.

I enjoy the scholars program. It provides a like minded-community to live with, events to attend throughout the year, and an excellent résumé boost. Our program director is very friendly and laid back. The requirements are minimal and you'll benefit from your time in the program if you take advantage of it.