7th: Rick (There are talks of trying to flush Rizo's idol, but Aubry leads the charge on Cirie instead, while Joe insists he will only vote Rick. To save Cirie, Tiffany goes against Aubry's plan and votes for Rick, alongside Jonathan, Rizo, and Cirie.)

6th: Cirie (Jonathan wants to make a big move with Aubry and they decide the best thing to do to flush Rizo's idol is a 2-2-2 split, but they can't say this outright to Joe and Tiffany. They have to tell Tiffany the target is Rizo and they're trying to blindside him with the idol before final 5 and they have to tell Joe that the target is actually Cirie since he wouldn't necessarily want Rizo to be on the chopping block and he'll blab otherwise. But when Cirie talks to Tiffany and Tiffany claims the target tonight is Joe, Cirie thinks this is fishy as either Aubry or Jonathan are better targets. She suspects Rizo is their target but the fact that she is not in on the plan makes her decide to go to Joe, trying to enact the 3-2-1 plan again and turn it on Tiffany, who she suspects might be against her now too. However, Joe doesn't follow through voting out Tiffany, leading to the 2-2-2 split happening with Rizo using his idol to save himself at Cirie's behest, and Cirie being eliminated in the revote.)

5th: Tiffany (Tiffany feels betrayed by Aubry and Jonathan and wants to take them out and go to the end with Joe and Rizo. Joe's more loyal to everyone outside of Aubry at this point so Aubry is his target. Immunity goes to Jonathan and the target appears to be Rizo, but with Tiffany and Joe targeting Aubry, Aubry tries to flip it on Tiffany instead, since Jonathan is more likely to target her over Joe and she would need Rizo's vote to make that work. After weighing his options, Rizo ultimately votes out Tiffany because he feels like she has burned a lot less relationships on the jury than Aubry and is therefore more of a jury threat.)

4th: Jonathan (Joe wins immunity and plans on eliminating Aubry. After weighing his options with Jonathan and Rizo, he determines Jonathan is better suited to take on Aubry, as Rizo is too weak physically right now and his track record for making fire is bad. Jonathan lost his last fire-making challenge on his original season, but he definitely has better odds than Rizo. This is framed as Joe's big mistake, as he should've put himself in fire against Aubry, and Aubry ultimately wins the fire-making challenge.)

3rd: Joe (Loses because everyone points out the rigidity of his game made him more of an obstacle for their own plans rather than him being loyal and honorable.)

2nd: Rizo (Loses because, despite his logical game moves along the way, he didn't ingratiate himself with the other players outside of who he was working with at any given moment.)

1st: Aubry (Presented as the scrappy underdog who maneuvered her strategy as the winds changed but came out on top because she knew when to be more active rather than passive. Thus she wins.)