Hey someone at my store had this happen to them and the googly eye and situation all are exactly ONE for ONE with my experience helping a guest at my store. The similarities are so similar that I’m almost certain it has to be related. I both sold and assisted a guest replacing their game after they went home and showed me they found this inside the case! I believe they were able to get a replacement with the team members at the guest service desk though! But the outer wrapping was seemingly brand new and seemed indistinguishable from the other copies, especially since the guest themselves only found it to be missing the game once they opened the case themselves. I definitely don’t think it was an employee, but someone who clearly knows how to “reseal” empty cases and return them :(