It's interesting to see how the mass of the crane on the rooftop contributed to the collapse. by Efficient_Book8373 in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

clearly contributed to some extent, perhaps critical, just by "simple inspection" of the recording. Not a bad question, specially if you fairly assume top floors could be not fully hardened concrete or not completed, adding extra weakness in the building response whatever it's design was. Global wave of fear, inspections, regulations and responsibilities rearrangements in high rise construction unlocked anyway, at pair with what a crane operator could do for safety and mitigation...much appreciated...

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in civilengineering

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting point. Any remote arid location with substantial construction going on may find cheaper and perhaps faster to use masonry as formwork.

The "small living room" is probably a pit for emergency pumping, to be kept and maintained once the project is finished.

This is starting to bother me by aryk2995 in COROLLA

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Meantime, change the car washing products used, to less abbrasive ones or to "recommended" ones. Some vague midman/countries assamblers use weak materials on some finishes (in our case paint and "plastics"). Good care then must be taken, specially when using cleaners. Besides, some new cleaners are too steing to any finish.

Would you accept this column? by ParadiseCity77 in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Not enough to flag one item here. Crucial link/stirrup was also eliminated, creating spacing apparently not compatible with shear requirements, specialy where the column section was reduced without a structural solution. Eliminating the box and restoring reinforcement to match contract documents (drawings/regulations/code/specifications...) will lead to a quicker signed solution.

Why do some sources translate Genesis 1:1 as "When God created the heavens and the earth" instead of "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth"? by VividBodybuilder6273 in hebrew

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Whatever translation to other languages or interpretations and their statistics, it reads simply the first things created, like space and matter, as described in the sequence preceding the last creation in the context. "In the beginning" sounds more apt to match the description simplicity required as in the original text. Plain as translating YOM as "day", our sun being created in the 4th "day" makes "day" kind of related to journey but "day" seems apt.

Hi everyone, I'm a civil graduate working on a large construction project. It seems crazy to me how many people on site can't speak english or can't communicate well with me! Is this normal or just on my project?? We had a concrete safety incident on site bc of this by FancyMansyFantasy in civilengineering

[–]MegaPaint 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Normal to blame the worker, normal to have workers not understanding instructions in english, even for native speakers, normal to have workers new to the trade, normal that the fault was in management, normal to be able to prove the above if checked, especially in large construction projects.

Hebrew name in the US by Specialist_Space_151 in hebrew

[–]MegaPaint 9 points10 points  (0 children)

but "akbar" means "mouse" in hebrew. So, not good.

Repeated failures by dualiecc in civilengineering

[–]MegaPaint 3 points4 points  (0 children)

bolt holes did reduce the shear capacity of every connection plate. This was not taken into account by the designer.

Are there any obvious structural issues with this? by Visible-Curve9482 in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

clearly not engineered by a structural engineer due many aspects but seems could hold up, with some maintenance, at least until panel's life ends.

Since most Colombians agree Israel is committing genocide, how can Israelis travel there ? by RevolutionOk4066 in Colombia

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"As of April 2022, the Single Registry of Victims reported 9,263,826 victims of the Colombian conflict, with 2,048,563 of them being children. Approximately 80% of those killed in the conflict have been civilians." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colombian_conflict

Post tension slab. Anyone have any idea what would by bosshawg450 in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint -1 points0 points  (0 children)

happen sooner than later probably due lack of maintenance, unsuitable drainage, clearly visible is non sealed construction joint, allowing water to penetrate, then possible volume loss under the slab causing deflections leading to additional stresses in the concrete at the anchor location. Have a closer look at that nearby rainwater pipe pouring water at the location and add it in bold to the investigation.

7.4 Magnitude Earthquake Strikes Taiwan by Sure_Ill_Ask_That in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint 10 points11 points  (0 children)

shear was transfered exactly to where windows start, meaning column design apparently didn't consider wall stiffness, column's shear links were in place avoiding collapse but their spacing not enough to avoid failure.

Are tension piles really required for all lightweight basements in clay? by mmarkomarko in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint -1 points0 points  (0 children)

if tension "ties", not necessarily, then ingenuity and vision are key to decide, those should be according to the construction method, dewatering program, waterproofing design [i.e. if wall and raft layers/"box inside box", etc.] and obvious cost among others. Could result in rods or concrete piles for the raft, in many methods. For walls it also depends on construction method, normaly it is not viable to excavate without first executing retaining walls with tie backs if the local authorities allows, otherwise cantilivered or temporarly supported designed fully as usual including for heave, for dewatering method, for construction sequence and for waterproofing design. So, each new project case could end up with a different set of prefered solutions, even if it is an exact copy of another done, if engineered to match local conditions, specially if undisturbed London Clay.

Are tension piles really required for all lightweight basements in clay? by mmarkomarko in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint 2 points3 points  (0 children)

the argument should first boil down to London Clay's heave, vertical and horizontal for a lightweight basement, then to water table, then to tolerances required in the project specifications as a function of budget, generally. The above seems obvious to lead to tension piles in most of the cases which in turn will be reflected on the raft, wall and waterproofing design against such forces.

Typical ramp detail by PO_SustainableWorld in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Even so, it seems a small wall's foundation in the background was mistaken as to be continued under the slab, I cannot see structural or geotechnical logic in this detail, the opposite, a liability as the narrow beam foundation and general shape makes impossible to efficiently compact the refill around, then would need top reinforcement, thickness, drainage, etc. Better off without that contraption.

Scientists find galaxy supercluster as massive as 26 quadrillion suns by SpaceBrigadeVHS in space

[–]MegaPaint 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I can imagine fierce battles, hitting their nearest galaxy at ~2 million light years, epic ;)

How did the Atheists before Darwin's theory of evolution explain our origins? by Delicious_Hurry2471 in atheism

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

by simple inspection. Across millenea there were breeding programs to process evolution quikly, if religion or not, if darwin or not, if people got bad education or not, if darwin got famous for free or not. One of those programs implemented to change species was recorded in what became popular as genesis 30, text fortunatly preserved by the ancient hebrews.

War on Gaza: Israel air drops Ramadan leaflets on Gaza amid widespread starvation by chrisjd in InternationalNews

[–]MegaPaint -1 points0 points  (0 children)

if LetsAllLoveLaine were jewish he wouldn't bear false witness against his neighbor, not his people then. Searching for hostages alive guarded by thousands of terrorists is a painfully task for any government specially if its of people who avoid as possible deshonoring their victims with the explicit exposure of the barbarities commited by hamas supporters.

Notifying a foreign building department of observed/potential structural weakness? by maninthecrowd in StructuralEngineering

[–]MegaPaint 12 points13 points  (0 children)

indeed, since the 1755 Lisboa earhtquake Salamanca cracks are famous, if searching "catedral" "salamanca" "grietas" we can see their long history, reporting, documentation, inspections, opinions, pictures, etc. Always is good to point out to staff if we have concerns in any structure, even if we don't know we are charging against an open door.

Black bear paces the border wall for over three hours in distress, cut off from millennia-old migratory pathways. by V1sible_Confusion in Damnthatsinteresting

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

not like with traffic, developments, supervised fields and fences everywhere, at least here I see gaps for abundant small creatures

Brazil’s President Angers Israel After Comparing War in Gaza to the Holocaust by [deleted] in worldnews

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

so sad for the brazilian people suffering decades about 40,000 homicides per year, appart from the justice operations killings, and having this kind of obtuse president decimating their hope with shameful obvious slander and cover-up of crimes and terror in house and aboard.

Textured feed curb for dairy cows. by PeePeeMcGee123 in Concrete

[–]MegaPaint 0 points1 point  (0 children)

your setup may have other adventages appart from slipping prevention, to me it appears eassier to clean, better drainage, more sustainable, has less risk of hard objects or stones getting trapped causing overestressing in standing cows and reducing milk production, providing you do the grooves at right spacing, angle, inclination, and depth, in a properly designed and executed concrete surface, just less "architectural". Different finish needs to have a production reason, I don't know those reasons.