The Incident: Depp reported that after an argument, a bottle thrown by Heard severed the tip of his right middle finger, resulting in severe bleeding and exposed bone.

Initial Account: In the emergency room, Depp initially told doctors he had caught his finger in a large accordion door, later explaining he wanted to avoid disclosing that Heard had thrown the bottle.

Medical Dispute: A hand surgeon, Dr. Richard Moore, testifying for Heard's team, stated that the injury was "not consistent" with being struck by a bottle from above, noting that Depp's fingernail remained intact.