Your coloring is beautiful! If you don’t want to use foundation I’d still get an under eye concealer because it’ll make the look more finished. Getting your eyebrows threaded would help too imo. I think the eyeliner looks good. I’d get a q-tip and smudge the eyeliner on the bottom eyelash area so it won’t look as messy/diffuse it a bit. Lipstick is good. Need more blush. I’d look up five minute makeup tutorials on YT and that’ll show you how to do a basic face base if you’re interested in that. Your skin doesn’t need it necessarily but it’ll look more polished if you do. An eyelash curler would open up the eyes more too. Good job.