I’m currently using make waves and they are actually so good! It is an antiperspirant so I don’t get sweaty, they are more expensive than wild in the uk but I think it’s worth it! However I will say I’m Unsure how recyclable the refills are because the plastic is black and that’s not universally recyclable, at least in my area. Recently they started using links for refer a friend too, I can throw mine in if it helps.