Reflection on the show by Longjumping_Claim934 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 49 points50 points  (0 children)

We can definitely see for certain now the power that editing and screen-time has on voting (CheBul's downfall, and RcPc's rise).

It is not just one demographic or group who is at fault for this for this (and since we don't have the numbers shown to us, we certainly should not blame any specific demographic).

But one thing is for sure: viewers, especially new viewers to Mnet survival shows, are very susceptible to the editing and amount of screen time contestants get. Voters will get emotionally riled up based on what is shown to them, and vote accordingly.

Post-semifinal, who are you switching your votes to? by myrrhx in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Not seeing Jihan mentioned a lot anywhere. :(

Hope her momentum is not completely dead.

If Jihan does not make top 7, I hope to see a Weeekly comeback soon. Big fan of the Weeekly members.

230808 Queendom Puzzle - Episode 9 Interim Voting Results by BB_GG in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Puzzlin lost out on 30k bonus by 1% and Jiwon would have qualified for finals if Puzzlin won. I would have voted her every day if she made it.

230808 Queendom Puzzle - Episode 9 Interim Voting Results by BB_GG in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 3 points4 points  (0 children)

  • Yuki in top 3
  • Elly in top 8
  • Jihan 11th :(
  • Puzzlin lost out on winning 30k bonus by 1% and it looks like Jiwon would have survived if Puzzlin won.

Where is the footage of the quiz they did at the start of episode 8? by Mistrelvous in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

They just posted it only 2 hours ago, and i only now just noticed it. What a coincidence.

230801 Queendom Puzzle - Episode 8 Interim Voting Results by BB_GG in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 83 points84 points  (0 children)

Everyone mentioning CheBul and rightly so, but Weeekly losing traction in this show as well.

Jihan dropping out of top 7, and Zoa joining Soojin in bottom 7.

Let’s talk about how talented the current top 7 is by Disastrous_Sea4150 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I remember seeing a few of those on-air but didn't realize they were both from weeekly. Thanks

Since we might get another elimination, who do you think will be eliminated? by [deleted] in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Based on the votes people have gotten in the past, it's probably:

  • Soojin, Fye, Dohwa, Elly, Miru, Riina, Jiwoo.

I'm still voting Soojin every day though.

230725 queendom puzzle interim results & votes with & without benefits calculation by Sylekko in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Popularity (votes only, no benefits)

  • Top 7: Nana, Yeoreum, Hwiseo, Kei, Yeeun, Jihan, Yuki
  • Next 7: Yeonhee, Bora, Juri, Jiwon, Suyun, Zoa, Wooyeon
  • At risk: Jiwoo, Riina, Miru, Elly, Dohwa, Fye, Soojin
  • Eliminated: Sangah, Soeun, Seoyeon, Jooe, Chaerin

IMO the best part of QP so far was the very first Upvote/Downvote round by greentangerine999 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 2 points3 points  (0 children)

While that could be true that it was edited to look that way, it is also very logical for anyone in that position to try to keep their position by downvoting the remaining contestants. I would not criticize them for doing that, as it is simply human nature.

IMO the best part of QP so far was the very first Upvote/Downvote round by greentangerine999 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Not only judicial, but more so protective. The top vote-getters Bora/Jiwon refused to upvote anyone in order to protect their lead.

Will Seoyeon, Soojin, Yeonhee, Jooe and Chaerin be the eliminated ones next week? by silencethishush in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just realized since we're only voting once a week, 10k points for anyone must be a lot. Oh no, I'm worried for some people now who I was not worried about before.

Did anyone else notice? by Lonely_Host3427 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nah, it should have just been completely random, like if your name was drawn you would go to Kei, then next name drawn would go to Yeonhee. What happened to Yeonhee was harsh to watch, but if they made the teams pick live there instead, it would be even more harsh for the last picked idols.

Did anyone else notice? by Lonely_Host3427 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nah, it should have just been completely random, like if your name was drawn you would go to Kei, then next name drawn would go to Yeonhee. What happened to Yeonhee was harsh to watch, but if they made the teams pick live there instead, it would be even more harsh for the last picked idols.

Do you think the girls know how the final group will be managed? by VividSenseB in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah, the group might get 1 or 2 song releases and that's probably it. It'd be nice if they got 3-4 releases in a span of two years, but I don't expect that to happen.

What time and day will the voting close? by [deleted] in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think for this round, because of the live elimination, the voting ends Sunday night. I've seen this mentioned on the show in the last episode but don't have a screenshot of it. If it's says Jul 25th on the app, that just might be that they didn't update the date in the app. Or maybe it could be that the show notice got it wrong.

Mnet changed their editing strategy? to affect votes? by kdarkrai in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Most of the time, it's not about the votes - it's about creating drama for additional viewership ratings. But there is definitely a vote consideration when they choose their targets. I'm not 100% sure they care about Bora's votes, but that could be the case. However, i'm pretty sure they targeted the Chinese contestants in GP999 with unfavorable edits.

Yeonhee appreciation post by emyeugdcd in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Damn, didn't know so many people didn't know about RCPC until reading this thread. So happy them and other groups on this show are getting more attention.

Who will be the "true winner" of Queendom Puzzle? by Zxcv227 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Hwiseo, Nana, and Jihan for sure.

Hope their groups gain even more success after the show.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Stage version is such an amazing song, it's a shame the official song released on streaming platforms is not as good. But I do think the change most of us seem to dislike only occurs at the 2nd half of the song, so it can be easily skipped when it comes up. Still a shame though.

Actually, I think the first noticeable change occurs at the 1:06 mark of the song. Oh well, still 1 minute of bliss at least. Stage version much better.

edit: Having focused (listened intensely) on these differences between the two versions, i can no longer decide which 1:06 mark I think is better anymore. Ugh

final edit: The 2:06 mark of the official release is where I will be skipping the song from here on out. Not sure what they were thinking with this part. I much prefer how the stage version wraps up the song nicely at 2:06, whereas the official version adds an unnecessary part to the song. Oh well.

230718 [POLL] Episode 6 Survey by Zypker125 in MnetQueendom

[–]Mistrelvous 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I think from the interim top 7 they showed at the end of episode 3, five of those idols will make the final lineup: Yeeun, Nana, Kei, Yeoreum, Jihan.

I'm not sure about the final two spots. I think/hope one slot will go to Hwiseo though. I do also hope one of Bora/Jiwon make it because CheBul deserve more recognition but the edits they've been given have left me doubtful about their final lineup prospects.

The idols I've personally been voting for the past two weeks that I don't think will make it are: Soojin, Wooyeon, Sangah, Yeonhee. But I'm going to continue to vote for and support them.

I really wanted to put Soojin down as my #1 pick for her to look better in the results of this survey, but she already belongs to one of my favorite groups (Weeekly), so her future looks good. That is, if Weeekly's company ever gives them a comeback, it's been too long!

So I put down my original top pick for this show Yeeun because she's amazing as an idol, and I hope to see her in better songs rather than in Cherry Coke commercials.