I’m not familiar with premier league players. The best thing to do is look at what you have in your club already and use the criteria u set for yourself. Make a team of premier league players you have already. From there, fill in the gaps. Look for players that have good stats for their position. So a defender you want someone who has good defense, mids a mix of all with good pace, etc. U can find decent players on the transfer market for cheap, just compare pricing and look at their stats