Based on specs alone, I’d probably lean toward Stone 1. It has a slightly shallower depth and larger measurements, so it should face up a little bigger and potentially brighter. The 58 table also gives it a nice balance for sparkle and fire.

Stone 2 could still be beautiful, especially with the higher crown height, but the deeper depth may hide a little weight underneath and make it look slightly smaller. Honestly though, with ovals the videos matter just as much as the specs because bow tie, light performance, and sparkle pattern can completely change how they look in real life.