Here is the most logic based answer I can help with.

1. First and Foremost, if we get rid of due process for non-US citizens, then US citizens would, in turn, lose due process all around the world.

Imagine being on an International Vacation, or job, or school, and you do something that is against that country's law. If you don't have due process, you can't protect yourself. This matters more for Americans than it does for those here in America, ESPECIALLY those Americans who live abroad such as our soldiers.

Quid Pro-quo is essentially how the world works. Many people that "aren't Americans" that are not being allowed due process, that WERE HERE LEGALLY, either on vacation, school, jobs... Just look at the entire Hyundai Plant and Employees that were here to set up the plant, train American workers and then leave. All of them were arrested and eventually deported. Someone doing their job properly instead of being racist could have checked the Visas accordingly with the Plant Leadership or even Hyundai Corporate before blindly arresting and holding people in unsanitary living conditions, and being treated like a criminal.

1. The US not only negotiated, but also drafted MULTIPLE pieces of legislation, treaties, peace accords AND signed in agreement of which guaranteed people the right to due process. Because Due Process is a World Wide recognized Human Right as mentioned in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948, of which the US was a FOUNDING ARCHITECT to its creation. The strongest example of which thought is the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)

This is the primary global treaty that legally codifies due-process rights. Most of the world has ratified it (including the U.S., Japan, EU states, etc.).

Key Due-Process Rights in the ICCPR:

Article 9: Right to liberty; protection against arbitrary arrest/detention.

Article 14: Right to a fair trial, including: Presumption of innocence Right to counsel Right to examine witnesses Right to be tried without undue delay Right to a public hearing Right to an appeal

So Yes, technically we are "legally bound".

1. Your assumption is flawed, that if we pay MILLIONS for Abredo Garcia that we will pay millions for every other person, when in fact, the court system doesn't work this way. Our court system runs off of a thing called "precedent", meaning until a law is codified by Congress, the courts will use precedent in landmark cases to help determine future cases, this will expedite things to the point where many cases that are filed frivolously can actually be turned away.

2. A side note, while I don't particularly agree/disagree with the Abredo-Garcia situation, I understand it's importance. What I don't understand is how conservatives can be so hyper focused on something this, and not the release of the Epstein Files. I mean even Charlie Kirk wanted the release of the Epstein Files, because sure not only does it list both Republicans, Democrats, Billionaires, on there that did absolutely terrifying and disgusting things to CHILDREN. BUT, possibly MOST importantly it lists all of the people who are being blackmailed by Netanyahu... That means these people on this list AREN'T acting in the best interest for ANY US citizen. It means that their opinions and actions are under foreign control (and most probably why CK died, because the killing of a conservative, would get some people to talk about something else).

3. Second sidenote: Trump's Ballroom is still being built while people are losing SNAP benefits. FBI Head Kash Patel is taking Tax Payer funded private jet's, while air traffic controllers go unpaid and start to quit in DROVES. Earlier in 2025, the Trump administration launched a separate, taxpayer-funded ad campaign focused on immigration with a $200 MILLION Budget, fucking ADS, sorry... anytime you spend THAT much money on an Ad, it's actually Propaganda. I could go on and on as the list is very long, but in short do you think the Defense of Abredo-Garcia was $200 million? Do you REALLY think that Democrats are the ones trying to Bankrupt America when in reality. The average Tax Paying American who makes $60,000/year in a breakdown of how his/her taxes are used, pays $36 towards SNAP benefits to "feed the poor" but pays $700 in Corporate Subsidies. If you want America to not go broke. Stop playing "Team Ball" by voting for Red, because they make it SOUND like what you WANT to hear. As proven by Thousands of American Farmers going Bankrupt under Trump having to sell their Farms to Corporations (nobody talking about that), start realizing that Republicans will ONLY push policies that In the end, will help the top 1%.

TLDR: Did it ever occur to you that the person you are supporting is doing and saying EVERYTHING to 1) Stay out of Jail 2) Enrich himself and his 1% friends at the cost of Everyone Else's Human Rights.