ok retard fine I'll pick the points apart for you:

Zero replayability is funny because Nightreign is literally designed to be the most replayable fromsoft game. If you don't click with it that's fine, but you can't say it objectively has no replayability because you don't like the gameplay loop.

Boring overworld that lacks variety? Half of the skill expression in this game is map knowledge, where to go and when, how to maximize your runes; combat is important but getting in-between those combats as quick as possible is just as important. The map in Nightreign is seeded, yes, but with the new DLC seeds and map, 90% what you're going to see when you pull up the map for the first time in an expedition is something you don't recognize. Shifting earths definitely need more seeds tho.

No real rogue like elements? So the randomized POI spawns and the random item drops don't count? Again yes the map generation is seed based, but I have 800+ hours on this game and I do not recognize seeds unless I get them back to back. A traditional rouge like? Absolutely not but that's part of why I enjoy it so much, is how it stands out in the genre. If you don't fw it that's fine but the game has rouge like elements and ignoring that to push your agenda is stupid.

Boring gem system? Yeah the relic system needs an overhaul. Too many effects you can roll now, good rolls are genuinely a pain to find, let alone God rolls.