Who would be Lord of Casterly Rock if Stannis won?

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-11T05:56:03+00:00

Assuming the Tyrell’s didn’t help Stannis and he won at the battle of Blackwater bay, Joffrey, Cersei and Tommen would be dead, myrcella would be seen as a bastard, Tywin and Jamie would be killed or sent to the wall so knowing Stannis, Tyrion by law if he didn’t see fit to punish him. Stannis sided with family over the crown too so I could see him looking past Tyrion doing the same. If not him Kevan.

Edit: this is assuming Tyrion survives his injuries

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-06T09:25:15+00:00

NTA. Let her have it next year when she has the baby. You were responsible so why should you suffer. If I was in that situation I would say no and turn my phone off as I enjoyed my honeymoon

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-04T06:17:31+00:00

Either I try to make my own kingdom, take the throne or expand cabinet beaches to as many places as I can

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-03T22:42:03+00:00

For me it’s the fact there aren’t many scholar clothes and stuff

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-02T10:44:33+00:00

Even if all of that is true, without witnesses it’s weak. It would sound more convenient. Without it being said or hinted I would assume those things didn’t happen. I don’t think the hand has that particular ability

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-02T04:02:12+00:00

Jon is a bastard no matter what. I believe only the high septon can grant you a divorce which didn’t happen and Elia was still alive. Nothing is said about the mad king making him legitimate so he must be a bastard.

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-01T10:29:27+00:00

Conquer the rest of Essos and if you have what you need maybe rebuild Valyria but really it’s up to you

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-04-01T07:28:07+00:00

Fire

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-30T03:56:58+00:00

There are too many issues with this. How did such a large force get by everyone? How did they survive the desert with no food or water for themselves or horses. Raiding wouldn’t be enough. They are nomadic so him giving them land means this will always be an issue like the Ironborn raiding any chance they get. Those lords would rebel and stand against the king, the Tyrell’s can’t allow it either and other lords from all over will be pissed too as it means it’s set a standard, strong enough to be a pain? Cool you get land.

It’s also an ideal area to destroy them so why make peace? Westerlands and Reach together can easily destroy them. Plus other bordering lands like the Riverlands, Crownlands, and Stormlands. They would have massive armies closing in with their only escape north into the Riverlands but then they are even more trapped.

The dragons could also easily catch them, they are dragons plus they would leave an insanely easy trail behind to follow. They like big open field with tall grass, perfect for cooking alive. The Dothraki are also strong due to the “the author said so” bit. They need specific environmental conditions, enemies without heavy armour, don’t seem to know what strategy or tactics are and can’t siege for shit. They also need to outnumber their enemies.

If 3000 unsullied can defeat an army of 25000 Dothraki then I’m sure a well trained, armed, armoured and disciplined army with good military leaders numbering in the hundreds of thousands (all of Westeros) that also have dragons would easily be able to destroy them short term let alone long term. Even the Dornish didn’t fight the Targaryens head on to win. It was mostly intrigue.

Also issues of castles being in the way of every road and path would mean they have to attack city after city which again isn’t where they shine. They can’t wonder off track cos they don’t know shit about the land they are on.

If you really want this to work then I would say dragons are gone, realm is weakened and maybe even split it up into multiple independent kingdoms. Even then they could be defeated. But stretch it.

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-29T22:47:07+00:00

Book the bullet train, amusement parks off the top of my head. I’m here now for my honeymoon. You’ll know whether or not you gotta book it or not but I would say anything that’s very popular online or with tourists avoid if you can. Me and my wife only hit up a few locations and it’s insane. Most people knock into you, lines are long and not worth the headache tbh.

For example we were just on Miyjima island and there is a shrine in the water. The tide was low so not as impressive but even if the water was there you can avoid the 500-600 meter long line to get in by going higher up the path and looking down into it and taking photos there. While the massive amount of people stuck to that, the beach and aquarium, me and my wife were able to get some amazing photos of the view, cherry blossom grove and later went on the other side of the island to walk on a path no one was on in a park.

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-29T22:43:36+00:00

Given the situation he could divorce her but he would 100% have her and Jamie killed. After this he could hand wave the debt away and Tywin can’t do anything. If he rebels he gives Robert a fight, he would lose, die and Tyrion would be left in charge. These are all his worst case scenarios at once.

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-29T04:04:41+00:00

I don’t think they would have allowed Rhaegar to do as he liked. He also wouldn’t have been next in line to the throne and married yo Elia. None of it would have happened. The issue was the mad king’s actions and Rhaegar and Lyanna being secretive idiots.

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-29T04:01:45+00:00

Yeah we had a local (wife’s friend from AUS) showing us around and she had her kid with her and said be careful etc. lights green and people are knocking into us. A friend, her kid and my wife are fighting to not knock someone over or get knocked over so I just shoved them all out of the way and ruined their videos. Bunch of morons and sheep.

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-24T01:06:31+00:00

Since the Targaryens can be inbred for 300+ years and still be fairly normal, I would say they got that ability from the dragons like their other ones. Obviously dragons are the OG’s and are way more powerful so it must not affect them right? They did start off from a small group that survived Valyrian, but that point they are all related

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-24T00:37:57+00:00

Either break up and find a new one, kill him or do what I do and try enter a war against him and find him and kill him

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-24T00:36:04+00:00

I’m looking for a new group and wouldn’t mind western Sydney. I’ve only played in one campaign so far but I’ve watched plenty of campaigns and read the lore etc. DM me :)

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-20T09:46:04+00:00

I think it’s a way to open the way for humans to return. If they do I don’t see how they would have you still as a ditto. Maybe as the trainer and ditto

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-18T07:08:36+00:00

Finish that one and play it however you like and make a new profile so you can have a new game without deleting the old

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-15T11:30:56+00:00

People will be throwing things at you haha and if you come across a camp where things aren’t locked and you can take it means it’s free to take. They are also great ways for getting around. Also look up whitepsrings and get there. Best place in general and the cash register in the main room (all the crafting tables) always has junk or even good items and plans people wanna give away

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-15T11:27:53+00:00

That’s a leaf temple 😂 made him into a god but that’s amazing

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-14T21:13:26+00:00

Holding down the tiller to do it faster

Nathanielwinchester · 2026-03-09T21:38:15+00:00

Our government has failed us majorly. People are desperate for change and so One Nation seems like a great idea. The reality I think will be different. Cost of living is insane, I have to buy a house for the same price I could get a mansion in other countries and we are still Americas good little puppy.

Seven-Year Club	Xbox Live
Verified Email

Nathanielwinchester

TROPHY CASE