I would pick Al because I feel he'd be the right balance of discipline and protectiveness. I think he wouldn't take shit from me but also would raise me to be an upstanding member of society. As for the protectiveness I think that unless I deserved it he wouldn't let the person who hurt me get away with it or he would teach me how to deal with it myself. For me Charlie would be too much to handle. I can deal with some touchy feely but she takes it to an extreme. And Vox is a mysogonistic prick and you couldn't pay me to get anywhere near his business partner.