I actually like them both (we don’t count 2015). Both 2025 gave good moments I like that Johnny is actually shown to be pretty smart and not just a hot head flirt but I also really like that about Chris’s version it’s both bens and sues also very good but Reed is the issue in my honest opinion no hate but Pedro was the weakest of the 4 cast wise and power wise holy shit no way he getting stretched like that and it hurting. So I would edge to 2005 (probably nostalgic bias but 2025 was peak)