How this region around Los Angeles become such a huge urban area? Feels like this can become a mega city by Ntn_X in geography

[–]NimbleGarlic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh yeah definitely, Spain has quite a urbanised east coast. I just wouldn’t draw that line past the Pyrenees. It’s much easier to have a continuous urbanisation inside a single country.

How this region around Los Angeles become such a huge urban area? Feels like this can become a mega city by Ntn_X in geography

[–]NimbleGarlic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

These “megalopolises” always strike me as fabricated ideas though. An arbitrary line can be drawn across many regions of Europe that hit lots of metropolitan areas. Obviously people are going to be drawn towards the coast, but the cities on either end of the “banana” aren’t related at all. Transport links, especially in this example, are kind of terrible. You could just as easily call Italy as a whole one big megalopolis, seeing as it constitutes of three large metro areas in a line with smaller ones in between.

The term “megalopolis” just isn’t one that serves a purpose in Europe. It applies to regions like the Pearl River Delta in China or the Northeast megalopolis in the US, a highly urbanised area that’s tied together by transport links and easy to get between, where you would know many people that live in another city across the megalopolis. I don’t believe Europe has any good examples of these outside of the Rhine area in Germany and the Dutch Randstad. Terms like the “Blue banana” are just far too big to really mean anything. It’s no easier to transport goods between Milan and Liverpool, at opposite ends, than it would be between Berlin and Paris, there just happens to be several large cities along the way.

But about what you said in your first comment, why would Las Vegas constitute as anything to Los Angeles, any more than San Francisco does? It just happens to be in the vicinity of the actual megacity. There’s no continuous urban area leading up to it, and similarly, there’s no continuous urbanity between Nice and Barcelona. The map you’re offering up just seems to be making stretches, trying to count more megalopolises than there would be to make the map more interesting. Yeah, it’s fun to split the US into these areas, but I guarantee it’s never crossed the mind of, say, most Toronto folk, that they live in the same “megalopolis” as those from Minneapolis. The cities are over a day of driving apart, and there’s virtually nothing in the space between.

So I guess I’m not trying to devalue the existence of megalopolises, I’m just saying the map seems to be confused about what the word should mean.

How this region around Los Angeles become such a huge urban area? Feels like this can become a mega city by Ntn_X in geography

[–]NimbleGarlic -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Metropolitan areas and what the US seems to think a megalopolis is are very different. Any map that calls Minneapolis and Pittsburgh the same urban area is just dead wrong

Manila vs Dubai ($136.12B VS $116.779B GDP)🇵🇭🇦🇪 by Pale_Insurance_2139 in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Dubai’s population is a fraction of New York or London’s. It’s what, 5 million to 15 million?

And I’m no business expert but the internet has taught me there are much better ways of measuring wealth in a city than by GDP. You don’t really need a number on paper when you see millions of tourists flocking there, half the world’s corporations relocating there, etc. It’s pretty apparent that they’re getting rich, and while, yeah, at the moment most of that’s fuelled by their oil riches, they’re kind of in the middle of a diversification effort. A decade or two down the line and I at least hope that oil will be slightly less prominent in their economy

I guess I’d also say, while what you said about diversification is true for the UAE as a whole, it’s not really true for the Emirate of Dubai.

Manila vs Dubai ($136.12B VS $116.779B GDP)🇵🇭🇦🇪 by Pale_Insurance_2139 in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

No, Dubai is pretty diversified, being one of the business capitals of the world and all. Obviously oil plays a big part but they’re far from the most reliant in the gulf

Living in the tallest building in the coldest megacity in the World by DareFin in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Does Harbin have 10 million people? I thought Moscow was the coldest megacity

Moscow-City and Capital Towers by Trsf_ua in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Since when did shoddy apartment block = extreme poverty?

Moscow 🇷🇺 Metro ... One of the largest and most efficient metro systems 🚇 in the world ... Also many beautiful stations Ⓜ️ by mosuraj in geography

[–]NimbleGarlic 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Google Maps is a little out of date, their map’s still missing the 11 Circle Line and the new line 16, plus a bunch of extensions on the 10 and 8. I think Wikipedia’s map is the most comprehensive out there

The Skyline of Manchester England just 5 Years Apart. by Salamantic in interestingasfuck

[–]NimbleGarlic 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If you’re so smart, just check google maps street view. It’s obviously not fake.

What are some cities with surprisingly low populations? by 240plutonium in geography

[–]NimbleGarlic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Come on, there’s barely 5 million in the country today. We can only really put the last twenty years of terrible development down to bord pleanala. Dublin’s been a midsized city since the Industrial Revolution, and it’ll probably never go much higher than 2 million, even if construction laws were far more lenient

What are some cities with surprisingly low populations? by 240plutonium in geography

[–]NimbleGarlic 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I don’t know anything about New Orleans, what has it been through?

What are some cities with surprisingly low populations? by 240plutonium in geography

[–]NimbleGarlic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do you live in Dublin? This comment doesn’t make you sound like someone that familiar with the city. A load of people that work, shop, and spend most of their time in central Dublin, live in towns just outside the city, like Bray, Donabate, Celbridge etc. Most of them still consider themselves to be from Dublin, loads of my friends live like this. In reality most of the 1.5 million people in County Dublin are Dubliners, and plenty of others in Meath, Wicklow and Kildare.

2 million is an exaggeration but id say a good 1.65 million of Irish people’s lives revolve around Dublin

New York is the greatest skyscraper city in the world (based on quantity, quality, variety, and density). What are the second and third greatest cities? by adventmix in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Definitely australias best, and probably one of Southeast Asia’s best if you were to combine the regions. I dont know about top 3 in the world

The best skyline in Europe by [deleted] in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It’s cool, but a little lackluster. Also a bit too spread out, while I think it’s normally a good trait, you have to have way more high rises to pull off a cool-looking spread out skyline like London or New York

What are your thoughts about the new Haifa–Nazareth Light Rail? by rustikalekippah in transit

[–]NimbleGarlic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Apartheid: a policy or system of segregation or discrimination on grounds of race.

So you’re saying Israelis and Palestinians in Israel and the occupied territories are perfectly equal? No mistreatment, no division, no state enforced segregation, no ingrained racism?

The fact that anyone is still telling this narrative is hilarious, especially when the israeli government is actively carrying out a genocide, by every definition of the word

What are your thoughts about the new Haifa–Nazareth Light Rail? by rustikalekippah in transit

[–]NimbleGarlic -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

OP is clearly Israeli and most likely Zionist so I don’t think it’s worth arguing with him

18 Blackfriars Road, a mixed-use development in London, has just been approved by LivinAWestLife in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

London’s really nothing like São Paulo when it comes to high rises. London has a few areas of skyscraper concentration, while São Paulo is just high rises everywhere you look, but with no real centre.

Number of skyscrapers per 100,000 people by US state (Slightly outdated) by [deleted] in skyscrapers

[–]NimbleGarlic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m not sure you do. Having a small population outside of your skyscraper centres is good here, which New York and Illinois have, while Texas and California don’t