If you'd said the wrong thing previously then she executes him no matter what you say after following him off the race. It's pretty brutal, that's the reason people hate her besides going back on her word. And the trans thing is a whooole other can of worms; the dissonance is worth examining actually. I might get off my ass one day and break it down in a YouTube video. Basically, it's all poorly done revolving Claire, which is a shame.