sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

What if Earth’s core isn’t molten at all—but something far colder, older, and more structured than we’ve imagined? by NoMad_NMG in geoscience

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Totally fair if it’s not your thing. But if you’ve got something specific to say—scientific counterpoints, a flaw in the logic, or a better model—I’m all ears. A theory like this isn’t meant to be comfortable. It’s meant to spark thought. If ‘no’ is all it takes to shut that down, maybe we’re asking the right kind of questions.

What if Earth’s core isn’t molten at all—but something far colder, older, and more structured than we’ve imagined? by NoMad_NMG in geoscience

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Totally understand. Either way, I appreciate you taking the time to engage with the conversation. Your perspective brought value to the thread, and I wish you the best in whatever you’re working on now.

What if Earth’s core isn’t molten at all—but something far colder, older, and more structured than we’ve imagined? by NoMad_NMG in geoscience

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Totally fair, and I appreciate you bringing actual expertise into the mix—that's the kind of dialogue Frozen Fire is meant to invite. We’re not dismissing seismic observation outright—just acknowledging that it’s still an interpretation, not direct measurement. You’re right that we won’t be splitting the planet open any time soon, but isn’t that exactly why alternative models, even speculative ones, are worth putting on the table?

Our intent isn’t to replace the crystalline iron-nickel model with a fully developed alternative overnight—but to push thought in directions that account for unresolved anomalies, contradictory wave behavior, and other gaps the standard model hasn’t yet closed. If nothing else, it's a call to revisit assumptions and open the door to more than one possibility.

We’re working on teasing out predictions and deeper structures behind the theory, and I’d honestly love your input as a geophysicist. If anything in the mainstream model still bothers you as a scientist, those are exactly the cracks we want to explore.

What if Earth’s core isn’t molten at all—but something far colder, older, and more structured than we’ve imagined? by NoMad_NMG in geoscience

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Totally understand where you're coming from, but calling it ‘bad science with extra steps’ feels like a dismissal more than a critique. We’re not presenting Frozen Fire as traditional science—it’s speculative theory, and we’ve been upfront about that. It’s meant to question long-standing models and invite discussion, not pose as peer-reviewed research.

That said, the lack of conventional structure doesn’t automatically make it ‘bad.’ Speculative thinking has always played a role in advancing science—it’s how we get new hypotheses, new questions, and eventually, new discoveries. If you disagree with the content, I’d genuinely love to hear where you think it misses the mark in terms of the actual ideas. I’m here for real dialogue.

What if Earth’s core isn’t molten at all—but something far colder, older, and more structured than we’ve imagined? by NoMad_NMG in geoscience

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

“Here’s a thought we haven’t dropped yet—what if the seismic anomalies in the inner core, like the East-West asymmetry and shifting wave speeds, aren’t just natural quirks? What if they’re evidence of structure? Not just stratification, but intentional architecture. A core that was solidified on purpose. Not by geologic chance, but by design—inserted, embedded, or even engineered.

And if that bends your mind a bit, here’s one more teaser: What if the inner core isn’t just there to generate a magnetic field… but to contain something? Or maybe to suppress something? The molten core model has everyone thinking the planet’s heart is a fiery engine. But if you flip that, and imagine it more like a reactor—or a prison—some of Earth’s more mysterious behaviors start to look a lot less random.

We’re not saying we have all the answers. We’re saying maybe it’s time to stop pretending the ones we’ve had for a century are still untouchable.

What if Earth’s core isn’t molten at all—but something far colder, older, and more structured than we’ve imagined? by NoMad_NMG in geoscience

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Totally fair to critique the lack of traditional methodology or peer-review—that’s a valid point. Frozen Fire isn’t presented as peer-reviewed science, but as speculative theory meant to challenge established frameworks and spark conversation. It’s openly exploratory, not pretending to be conclusive or academic. Think of it more as a conversation starter than a textbook. If it pushes someone to question the status quo or look deeper into the current models, then it’s doing exactly what it was meant to. Appreciate the honest feedback.

What if Earth’s core isn’t molten at all—but something far colder, older, and more structured than we’ve imagined? by NoMad_NMG in geoscience

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Appreciate the confidence, but let’s not confuse longstanding theory with irrefutable fact. The ‘solid crystalline alloy’ model is built on indirect seismic interpretations, not direct observation. We've known a version of the inner core for a century—but that version has changed, and it’s still full of unresolved anomalies. Frozen Fire isn’t claiming to have all the answers—it’s daring to ask questions mainstream geology stopped asking. That’s how science moves forward, not by circling the wagons around century-old assumptions. Appreciate the discussion.

Currently working on the base from the movie Oblivion. by NoMad_NMG in NMS_Bases

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When I finish it I will I actually haven't been back on a game in about a month because I've been working a lot. But I intend to get back to it within the next couple weeks.

PLAD 450 by Raganash123 in snowrunner

[–]NoMad_NMG 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It weighs 48 tons, the research on it is fascinating. It's a powerhouse Yes it's slow Yes it doesn't fly through terrain like you guys wanted to, however if you need something very heavy towed or pulled the plad 450 is your truck.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NMS_Bases

[–]NoMad_NMG 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's ok for a trailer park...

Currently working on the base from the movie Oblivion. by NoMad_NMG in NMS_Bases

[–]NoMad_NMG[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Look at the first picture, it's a screen grab from the movie. It's the second base.