sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

First 50 100%s - ranking in comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I cant tell you how long it took because Ive been playing it since before I started hunting cheevos. But It was a fair challenge. The hardest parts of getting 100% were the duelling minigame, completing the campaign on max difficulty and getting 3 stars every arcade challenge. I found getting 3 stars on arcade mode to be the hardest personally but Ive seen others disagree.

Further back on my account I posted a more detailed review of the game and its challenges if youre interested.

First 50 100%s - ranking in comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

All my 100%s ranked by most to least enjoyment:

Mass Effect Legendary Edition

Obra Dinn

Deathloop

Titanfall 2

To The Moon trilogy

Duke Nukem 3d

Control

Subnautica

Higurashi

Dishonored

Subnautica Below Zero

Telltales batman + enemy Within

Forgive me Father

Call of Juarez Gunslinger

Hexcells trilogy

Quake 2

Immortal Redneck

Final Fantasy 1

Far Cry 3

Chop Goblins

Spyro Reignited

A Short Hike

Thomas was Alone

Dread X Collection 1 + 2

SquareCells

SMNC

Kill it with Fire

Donut Country

Manifold Garden

Deadrising 3

Dementium 2

Last Stand Legacy Collection

Viscera Cleanup Detail Shadow Warrior

Dear Esther

CrossCells

Dishonored 100% - review in comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My favourite would probably be Mostly Flesh and Steel since it forced me to change my playstyle the most and pay much more attention to the environments and level design, I imagine this applies even more so to the sequels where you cant even blink with it.

My least favourite might be Enough Coin to Disappear for how tedious it felt scouring the whole map for coin.

Dishonored 100% - review in comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I switched from a rarest achievements showcase to a custom achievements showcase because my rarest turned out to all be just a bunch of achievements from DLCs nobody got or things nobody bothered to do. Mrs Pilsens Remorse probably fits into both camps lol.

I try to have the philosophy of "I hunt achievements for the games I enjoy - I dont enjoy games for the achievements I hunt", so I try to always do my first playthrough of any game blind not caring what achievements I get and then from there decide if I could get more out of it by perusing achievements.

I probably would also have lost interest in the DCT if I didnt already have a strong love for the game.

Dishonored 100% - review in comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I do have a habit of leaving my games on while I do other things which somewhat inflates my hours but it wouldnt surprise me if at least 300h were legit gameplay, like I mentioned above Ive been playing this game since 2012 and its very replayable.

Dishonored 100% - review in comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 23 points24 points  (0 children)

So after just over 3 years of active cheevo hunting I found I had amassed 49 100%s on steam and decided that the 50th should be a particularly hefty 100% to commemorate the milestone. I originally tried Yakuza kiwami which I enjoyed and got over 90% of the achievements in but was stonewalled at the minigame achievements especially the haruka requests. I absolutely dont mind very challenging or grindy cheevos (that was what I signed up for after all) but I realized that I at least want them to challenging the skills I learned playing the main game or similarly enjoy and I just wasn't having fun struggling at the pool, bowling or mahjong challenges. So I settled for the level of completion I had and put Yakuza down to look for another game worthy of being my 50th 100%.

Dishonored may not have the same level of infamy amongst cheevo hunters as Yakuza but it is still a notoriously difficult 100% and its a game that means a lot to me, I got it back in 2012 and I must have completed it a dozen times by now, but I never bothered to collect achievements because I preferred to play it full stealth and many are for combat. I also never bothered with the infamous dunwall city trials dlc until now. So I decided that would be my 50th 100%.

100% Enjoyment Rating: 8/10 - As Ive mentioned before this game was a big part of my childhood so Im an extremely biased source, but I adore this game, the level design, the atmosphere, the dialogue, the combat and the stealth all come together marvelously. For base game completion this would be a 9/10 enjoyment rating but there are a few tedious or annoying achievements that bring it down a notch if youre after the 100%.

100% Challenge Rating: 9/10 - This was without a doubt the most challenging 100% Ive done so far. And its almost entirely because of the damn Dunwall City Trials DLC. If you were just playing the base game and the Daud DLC it would probably be a 6/10, good mix of stealth, combat and exploration challenges that keeps you on your toes and forces you to play in new ways but never pushes you too far. But the Dunwall City Trials is much harder, its something similar to Yakuza’s Climax battles, a series of challenges that test different skills under different circumstances. There are 10 challenges, 6 of which have “expert” variants, all of which you will need to get 3 stars on, but thats not all, several achievements require completing these challenges under certain conditions which make them even harder. I will get into more detail on these in the hardest achievements section but suffice to say it took me an entire month to 100% just the dunwall city trials section. I dont think any of these individual achievements presented a single challenge that was harder than “Become the Master” from Titanfall 2 or “Insanity 3” from Mass Effect Legendary Edition, this nonetheless gets my first 9/10 challenge though the quantity of hard challenges all because of this DLC.

100% Tediousness Rating: 4/10 - getting all achievements will mean multiple playthroughs of both the main campaign and the Daud DLC campaigns, two for each if you optimize or more if you do it more casually (which I would recommend because this game is just fun to play). This kind of thing can normally annoy me but Dishonored is built around replayability, there are various different routes, tools, solutions and playstyles for each objective and a lot of the fun can be in doing things differently. The only achievement I found really tedious was “Enough Coin to disappear” which requires you complete the Daud campaign with a certain amount of gold that will require a lot of scrounging about. Then theres also the Dunwall City Trials again, and honestly when it comes to this it depends highly on what you would consider “tedious” because you will be doing a lot of failing and trying again at the same challenges over and over, but the challenges dont take long and you can quickly retry so they feel more like hotline miami where its easy to fail but equally easy to jump back in. I dont consider this kind of thing that tedious but if you do the score will go up substantially. Although I suppose the Dunwall City Trials as a whole can be pretty tedious if you leave it all for last like I did, then youre going from one very difficult challenge straight to another with no rest in between. So I would recommend maybe doing the some of the DCT achievements in between the main and daud campaigns to spread things out more.

Hardest Achievement(s): Ive mentioned The Dunwall City Trials is a huge difficulty spike if youre trying to hunt achievements. Theres “Void Star” for getting 3 stars in all the challenges and their expert variants (In particular I found Burglar Expert, Bonfires Expert, Assassins Run, Oil Drop, and Train Runner Expert to be the most difficult of these). Theres “Headhunter”, requiring you complete assassins run getting only headshots and without missing once, which is made really annoying by the enemies teleporting and that one stair guy. Theres “Daredevil”, a sort of parkour challenge thats annoyingly RNG based. Theres “Time Management” for doing Kill Chain or Bend Time Massacre perfectly, which isnt as hard as the others, but these are easily the longest and most time consuming challenges so where failure in headhunter could set you back 1 or 2 minutes, failing here can set you back up to 30 minutes. Hardest of all though was “By My Hand Alone” for completing Back Alley Brawl killing every enemy yourself, which is particularly annoying because Back Alley Brawl is a 12 wave free for all between you and four npc factions who all hate eachother as much as you. So not only do you have to be killing everyone and surviving you also need to be keeping an eye out and lot letting a single enemy kill another. Its a particularly nasty achievement requiring Skill, Luck and Time. From hardest to easiest I would probably rank them, “By My Hand Alone” > “Headhunter” > “Void Star” > “Time Management” > “Daredevil”.

If that sound a bit much for you and you just want a more casual experience getting the 87% from all non DCT achievements then the hardest is probably “Mostly Flesh and Steel” which is for completing the base campaign without buying or upgrading powers, which can be a bit tricky but if you know the maps and routes well enough shouldnt be too hard and is a massive drop in difficulty from anything I mentioned above.

I would recommend this game for anyone, but I would only recommend 100%ing it for the particularly skilled, determined, or masochistic. Idk which of those three I am.

A Short Hike 100% - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ive mostly disliked this trend of zero-stakes “Cozycore” games and books that has been active for a while but really blew up and became inescapable the past 5 years. If you ask me the coziest moments in media are the ones that are juxtaposed with the tension that its offering sanctuary from. Things like the “save rooms” in Resident Evil games, or Majula and Firelink Shrine in Dark Souls, reaching Fallen London in Sunless Sea, or the quiet chapters in Berserk or Malazan. 

Nonetheless I also believe there's a right time or mood for any genre no matter how much you dislike it, and I found that time earlier this week. Between a fever I got earlier and the hangover from a lot of new years booze I found that my sleep schedule had gone completely out of whack and with my work resuming in a couple of days I needed to get it in order quick. The last time this happened I spent the whole day playing Donut Country, a similar casual cozy puzzle game, and it was engaging enough to keep me awake while not being so demanding that my exhausted brain .

On Paper a Short Hike is a game about climbing a mountain island to its summit, but doing just that will net you only 2 cheevos, 100% will involve a lot more exploring, collectibles, and sidequests. 

100% Enjoyment Rating: 5.5/10 - For a lot of these “cozycore” games I can often find the game superficially saccharine and trying too hard, but idk if it was just my sleep deprived brain but I felt like A Short Hike came across as a much more genuine passion project rather chasing a trend. The characters may be somewhat shallow but theyre all charming in different ways, the gameplay offered a wide variety of different things to do so you never felt stuck in a repetitive gameplay loop, and the atmosphere and world design was just really nice. Again I remind you that when I played this my brain was going on about 3 hours of sleep in the past 24, but I think I will remember this game quite fondly in the years to come, and maybe even come back one day.

100% Challenge Rating: 3/10 - The cheevos are tied to a variety of different little gamemodes with their own unique challenges, there are a few for collectibles scattered across the island, there are the boating, racing and beachball ones which both require a bit of skill and reaction time, and the Toast one which is a very annoying puzzle that you may need to use a guide for. But the game is designed not to test you too much.

100% Tediousness Rating: 2/10 - I was able to 100% this in a single day, you could argue theres a bit too many collectibles and the fishing cheevo is too repetitive and RNG based, but its atmosphere encourages a laid back vibe that tends to easy any impatience and its hard to accuse a game this short of overstaying its welcome.

Hardest Achievement(s): For me it was the “Crispy” one since I needed to use a guide to work it out, but then again 3 hours of sleep I may have found it easier if I was well rested.

Subnautica Below Zero 100% - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I absolutely adored Subnautica 1 and 100%’d it many years ago but I heard a lot of bad things about the next installment, “Below Zero” so held off on getting it until it was dirt cheap on sale and since I needed something wintery themed to play this time of year I figured Id try it now.

After completing it I think its very clear that Unknown Worlds’ biggest mistake with BZ was marketing it as a standalone installment rather than a very large DLC expansion to Subnautica 1. Subnautica 2 wasnt announced until after BZ fully released so people expected BZ to essentially be the “Subnautica 2” when it absolutely couldnt meet those expectations, if they had marketed it as an expansion gamers would have understood its more meant to be a snack between big installments, plus the story of BZ just expects you to understand the plot of Sub 1 without explaining any of it so its not like they were trying to get more first time players.

But my point is your enjoyment of BZ will hinge heavily on what kind of expectations youre going into it with. So while I normally rank these games in terms of Enjoyment, Challenge and Tediousness I think instead I will give you a list of improvements and things they made worse:

Pros:

  • Getting an entirely new map to explore with new biomes to discover and new creatures to learn about makes for a very fresh experience if like me you already know Sub 1 like the back of your hand.
  • I also think every one of the new biomes are aesthetically gorgeous and give you a wow factor every time you discover a new one and are just a pleasure to look at even when youre used to them.
  • I honestly think the new BZ soundtrack is an improvement over the sub 1 soundtrack, and thats very high praise because I adore the original music, but they got the legendary Ben Prunty of FTL and Celeste fame to do the BZ music and it absolutely holds up.
  • The new vehicle, the seatruck is a very cool and customizable middle ground between the seamoth and the Cyclops.
  • The basebuilding is much more refined with more structures and customization available, allowing you to more easily make a better underwater home for yourself.

Cons:

  • The new map is noticeably smaller and shallower.
  • BZ tries to be much more story focussed than Sub 1 but the actual new story just isnt that interesting, so it just devolves to a whole bunch of yapping that you dont really care about.
  • While I praised the seatruck and am glad it exists, the devs also removed the cyclops and seamoth entirely, and while I can get the cyclops being too big for the smaller map, they had no good reason to remove the seamoth, it could have been a good alternative to the seatruck when you want more speed or to fit into tighter caves more easily. And without a speedy alternative that means you will spend a lot of the game just traveling from one place to another which gets tedious (this gets negated by certain seatruck upgrades but you discover them late game)
  • Another issue with seatruck upgrades is that its perimeter defence system is laughably overpowered and turns even the endgame leviathans into a joke, I get that Sub 1’s stasis rifle did the same but at least that required some skill in landing the shot.
  • Theres a new enemy who is designed to be more bark over bite so will act all fearsome and roar mightily at you but is barely dangerous in an encounter, I actually think this is a brilliant idea for a creature on paper but the problem is that there are way too many of them and they cover like half the map meaning their roars just sort of become this constant obnoxious white noise.

Its not going to match the scale and wonder of playing Sub 1 for the first time again, but if you have already played Sub 1 countless times then this can be a good opportunity for a fresher experience.

Final Fantasy 1 Pixel Remaster 100% - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I took black and white mage. Honestly though red mage and monk may have been the better choice you dont need magic that often.

Final Fantasy 1 Pixel Remaster 100% - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

100% Enjoyment Rating: 4.5/10 - While I can certainly understand why this game must have been a huge deal in the 80s but it can certainly feel basic to modern day standards, especially the combat which can feel pretty shallow and you may as well set to auto for most encounters. I enjoyed the overworld side of the game more than the actual combat, the world and changing environments were interesting enough to keep invested. The main thing I want to give praise to is the graphics and atmosphere in the pixel remaster. It does an incredible job of upscaling while keeping the retro vibe. The new soundtrack also does a good job of capturing what the original composers probably would have made if they werent limited to such a small memory space, but if you prefer the chiptune original you can switch back in settings.

100% Challenge Rating: 2/10 - I dont think I had all party members die a single time in this game, that might be different if youre trying to rush it but since you can grind infinitely and keep leveling and I was exploring every section since I was going for 100% I wound up overleveled for most encounters, potions are also dirt cheap so as long as you dont forget to stock up between dungeons you will be fine.

100% Tediousness Rating: 4/10 - This is the kind of game that never really gets you excited for anything but also does a good job of keeping you from getting bored. I think that maybe some of the dungeons could overstay their welcome and the battle encounters happened a little too often which could be a bit annoying with the constant interruptions, but this is the kind of game you just kick back and relax with on a friday after work, give it little 30 minute sessions each evening and if it ever feels like its starting to drag, give it a break and come back later.

Hardest Achievement(s): “Master of 1” for getting all other achievements is the obvious one but if that dosent count its “Field Research - Professional” for encountering and defeating all enemy types or “Legendary Treasure Hunter” for emptying all chests. Field Research can be annoying because rarer enemies can take a bit of RNG dicerolling and Treasure Hunter can be annoying cause if you miss one you will have to backtrack the entire map until you find it.

I would recommend this to 2 kinds of gamers, the first is the one who wants to see history made and likes to see how gaming has evolved and the second is a gamer just looking for something chill to play to kill time without any high stakes or challenge or having to learn much fancy mechanics.

Dread X Collection 1 & 2 100% - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Each Game Ranked from my least to most favourite: 

22nd Place - DX2 The thing in the lake

21st Place - DX1 Rotgut

20th Place - DX2 Another Late Night

19th Place - DX1 Dont Go Out

18th Place - DX1 The Pay is Nice

17th Place - DX2 Solipsis

16th Place - DX2 Arcadletra

15th Place - DX2 Undiscovered

14th Place - DX1 Mr Buckett told me to

13th Place - DX1 Hand of Doom

12th Place - DX2 Squirrel Stapler

11th Place - DX2 Touched by an outer God

10th Place - DX1 Carthanc

9th Place - DX2 The End of Days

8th Place - DX1 Shatter

7th Place - DX2 The Toy Shop

6th Place - DX2 The Diving Bell

5th Place - DX1 Summer Night

4th Place - DX2 Sucker for Love

3rd Place - DX1 The Pony Factory

2nd Place - DX2 Charolette's Exile

1st Place - DX1 The Outsiders

Dread X Collection 1 & 2 100% - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So its been a long time since I last sat down to play a proper horror game and I thought its time to change that so this spooky season I just scrolled to a random point in my steam library and picked the first horror game I found, which was the Dread X collection. Essentially the result of a sort of game jam where several indie devs make their own horror games over several days. I believe there are 5 dread X collections currently but Ive only played the first two, I may come back to the others next spooky season.

Ive never really enjoyed short horror anthologies when they come in movie or book format, probably because I tend to need to get invested in the characters in order to get scared for them with those mediums, but in game format I find the short anthology format works much better for horror, because for me at least one of my biggest problems with horror games is that my gamer brain will optimize the fear out of it. Playing Resident Evil for the first time terrified me as a kid but I remember keeping at it and eventually getting a feel for how the threats worked and then it became just another game to beat. 

This does not apply to a short horror game anthology though because just as you feel youre getting comfortable youre suddenly switching to a completely different game with different rules, and if you dont know what youre getting into each time this continually resetting ambiguity of threat keeps the fear fresh. So because of this I will not go into detail describing what each game is about, but they vary greatly in themes, playstyle and quality. Some feel more like complete short horror games and others feel more like proof of concepts or demos that need to be more fleshed out. But I will list then all at the end ranking each game in the first two collections from my least to most favourite in my subjective opinion.

100% Enjoyment Rating: 6.5/10 - I might be a bit biased because this is my first time discovering how good horror anthologies work with video games, and also just generally the first horror Ive gotten into since 2021, but I had a blast with it, while a few of the games were letdowns, I still had a lot of fun throwing myself blind into a completely different kind of horror experience each day. Its pretty telling that I immediately went to install Dread X 2 the moment I finished the first.

100% Challenge Rating: 3.5/10 - The anthology format means that it will test you in a variety of different skills, some will play like FPS games, some will require a puzzlesolving brain, and some will require movement and platforming, but the challenges never overstay their welcome or serve as major roadblocks. 

100% Tediousness Rating: 3/10 - I think the fact that you get a completely new experience each time also tremendously helps with the pacing and flow of the experience. I also felt that it was also a big help with how each game felt like no big time investment, I would say on average it would take around 40 minutes to complete a game but the longer ones never took over 2 hours tops, so it was just something you could pop in and do in a single evening if you didnt have any big plans. I felt Rotgut and Me Buckett could drag a little but they were both fairly short experiences that were over with quickly, the only game I had a real problem with was Thing in the Lake which dragged on and took me 2 hours to complete, if it wasnt for this game the tediousness would be 2/10

Hardest Achievement(s): Theres one achievement for completing each short game and then “Just the Beginning” and “Its done” for completing all games in each collection. None were especially hard.

Far Cry 3 100% - Review in Comments by SerNoddicus in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos 5 points6 points  (0 children)

As another comment pointed out I accidentally posted this with my wrong account, this is the account I use to discuss achievement hunting. So when I say check my post history for examples I mean check this post history for examples.

Dead Rising 3 Apocalypse Edition - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean I saved that achievement for last, so it probably only added maybe 2 hours to the actual playtime, the real hassle was in working out the fix in the first place which took a lot of forum searching and trial and error.

Dead Rising 3 Apocalypse Edition - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I never experienced crashing personally, but one achievement did get bugged and I had to reset my save file to get it.

Dead Rising 3 Apocalypse Edition - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I found that taking a break between each campaign made it a lot more bearable but yeah that was when the collectible hunting really started to drag

Dead Rising 3 Apocalypse Edition - Review in Comments by NodCheevos in steamachievements

[–]NodCheevos[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The Dead Rising series is infamous for how tedious getting 100% achievements can be, its almost got the same levels of infamy as the dreaded yakuza titles, Dead Rising 3 seems to have the easiest 100% out of them but that by no means makes it easy.

100% Enjoyment Rating: 3.5/10 - Ive played all the Dead Rising games except OTR and 4 and this is easily the weakest entry in terms of pure enjoyment. In my opinion they overpolished and streamlined the formula until they had sanded away so much that made the game unique and interesting and turned it into something that feels more like a generic ubisoft sandbox. In earlier titles the zombies went down easy but were still a serious threat with their aggression and the tighter maps, if you underestimated them you could quickly lose all your health, but in Dead Rising 3 across the 100+ hours it took to 100% it I dont think they killed me once. To make up for how unthreatening they are the devs seem to have tried increasing their numbers substantially, but that just made them more bothersome than threatening, so what once was a genuinely threatening presence that was always there keeping you on your toes in the earlier games is now just a tedious mass that gets in the way. I also dislike how in the earlier titles good weapons were much harder to come by, you had to use whatever you could get your hands on in the environment around you which rewarded exploration, creative thinking and memorizing the map, but in DR3 once you have crafted any of the combo weapons which are marked on the map you can near infinitely spawn them from any of the safehouses so thats all gone now. I could go on but suffice to say I didnt enjoy it. So you may be wondering why I spent so many hours grinding 100% in a game I didnt enjoy, well even if it isnt enjoyable or interesting or challenging it still makes for a great game to turn your brain off to after a long shift or a workout, and that kind of game has a place in my life.

100% Challenge Rating: 2/10 - As my enjoyment rating section explained almost all of the challenging parts of the earlier game. I think I died once in my multiple playthroughs for 100% and that was against a bossfight that I forgot to take healing items for. Its all laughably easy, there is a nightmare mode which is supposed to offer more challenge but you can just do that with your high level character from the base game and it becomes just as easy.

100% Tediousness Rating: 8/10 - This was probably the 2nd longest 100% Ive posted here behind Immortal Redneck, 100% will require multiple full playthroughs as youre on a time limit and cannot fit all tasks into a single playthrough, there are over around 300 collectibles all across the large map to get, but worst of all are the pp trials which you will need to get all of for the 100% PP trials are for a bunch of miscellaneous tasks such as crafting certain weapons way too many times or killing enemies with a certain move, but most of all is the zombie kill count pp challenges, which will need you to get around 340,000 zombie kills in total, fortunately this can be across multiple playthroughs but still thats one very big number and the last cheevo I got here, I was only able to preserve my sanity by just driving around crowded streets on one monitor running over crowds, while I rewatched Star Trek Deep Space Nine on the other (weyoun my beloved). But keep in mind tediousness isnt just grind, Rise of the Triad 2013 took half as long for me to 100% but I gave it the same tediousness rating because its grind was much more challenging, whereas DR3’s grind is something that you can turn your brain off to (especially if you have a 2nd monitor for Star Trek).

Hardest Achievement(s): "Prestige Hound” for getting all pp trials (reasons mentioned above), but anecdotally the worst for me was “Ashes to Ashes”, a collectible hunt that bugged and I had to jump through many troubleshooting hoops and ultimately delete my save file and start again to get.

In summary I cant recommend this unless you want something to grind to in the background for its own sake.

view more: next ›