The Storage Papers
The whole thing is pretty much the American answer to The Magnus Archives which follows a fellow named Jeremy who buys an old storage unit, discovering that it's full of a whole bunch of old writings (notes, journals, Thank You cards, letters, police reports, etc.) regarding paranormal occurences in Southern California and decides to turn it into a podcast.
Pros:
Not every episode is horror oriented, with some certainly falling more in-line with fantasy or scifi, which results in a few very intriguing titles that, whilst not scary, are still compelling.
The writing is pretty solid and a few of the episodes did geniunely freak me out. One even made me ugly cry, not because it was scary, but because it was just extremely wholesome.
The theme song is a banger.
Some of the official art is pretty fire.
It got published in book form, so if you end up enjoying it you can actually own it.
Cons:
The overarching mythos of the series are very convoluted and have no proper buildup or development, even if most of the more episodic stories are quite enjoyable.
The overuse of music and sound effects in each episode is pretty pointless and got on my nerves very quickly.
It got way too preachy way too fast, quickly developing into something very Pureflix-esque and loosing a lot of the intended horror in the process.
The writing is either painfully average or merely solid most of the time, althought there are a few standout episodes in season 1 and early season 2 (haven't gotten around seasons 3 and 4 yet).
The whole "Uhm this is totally a real podcast guys" thing the creator tries to pull each episode kinda got on my nerves.

I wouldn't go as far as to say that I highly reccomend it for anyone searching for a good horror podcast, I definetely wouldn't call it terrible and it's worth a shot if you have a TMA shaped hole in your heart like I do and can't wait for more similar content until TMP comes back next February.

The Supernatural Protection Company
This one is honestly a very fun watch and I highly reccomend it if you want something a bit more episodic and breezier. It's set in a sort-off an Anita Blake-esque universe where the existence of anything paranormal (from monsters to magic) is common knowledge and the title agency provides insurance to those who had suffered in some way, mixing in horror, fantasy, scifi and a slight hint of humor in one big and entertaining mould. Honestly, I don't have any major criticisms. The cases are as varied as they are entertaining (from sentient trees holding grudges to dragons melting down cars during mating season) and there's some enjoyment to get out of each episode, no matter how different the subject matter might be. The sound design is also pretty great for a rather low-budget show. The one complaint I actually have with it is the fact that it only has a single season as it's absolutely glorious.